Nestled away on the rooftop of Tenikai General Hospital is the unconventional Department of Investigative Pathology headed by the eccentric Dr. Takao Ameku. The tiny department, consisting of Takao and her sole resident Yuu "Kotori" Takanashi, treats complex cases that most other departments within the hospital cannot resolve on their own.
The mystery-obsessed Takao always tries to insert herself into cases that capture her fancy—much to the dismay of her colleagues and the police. Even if her meddling creates more problems for the hospital and those around her, none can deny the brilliance that the young department head exhibits as she weaves a diagnosis together. No matter the specialty, no case is impossible for Takao and a somewhat reluctant Takanashi to solve.
[Written by MAL Rewrite]
Nenhum episódio encontrado.
Comentários
KANLen09
Ameku M.D.: Doctor Detective — Are we ready for a House M.D. derivative anime drama just yet? I sure hope so... In the realm of television dramas, I feel that there was a unique area that used to fascinate and blow people's minds ever to grace the small screen, and it's in the segments related to hospitals, medicals, and the like. Sure, you have the all-time favourites of shows the likes of Grey's Anatomy, House M.D., and the lesser-known Scrubs, which is what should be in the minds of anyone who watched the best of the best hospital dramas. Though I'd beg to differ that hospitaldramas outside of the US do have their popularity as well, namely one of Japan's most consistently highly-rated hospital/medical drama shows of the 2010s, that being Doctor-X: Surgeon Michiko Daimon (if you have not heard of this long-lasting TV drama, I highly suggest you go and watch it; it rivals that of American counterparts being similar and great.)
The reason why I bring up Doctor-X: Surgeon Michiko Daimon, is on the basis of the one show where the hospital/medical drama has made somewhat of a resurgence: novelist Mikito Chinen's Ameku Takao no Suiri Karte a.k.a. Ameku M.D.: Doctor Detective, which explores a rather unorthodox and unconventional doctor in the face of hospital politics and diagnoses, just like how Dr. Gregory House (played by Hugh Laurie) played his role to exact mimicry. Though I should give a bit of context as to who exactly Mikito Chinen is, given his rather rich background.
Born in Nanjo City, Okinawa Prefecture, novelist Mikito Chinen is actually a certified physician, having graduated from Tokyo Jikei University School of Medicine and being a certified doctor of the Japan Society of Internal Medicine. That is his realistic profession, but deep down he wanted to become a novelist as a dream from his young days, and this started when he wrote a short detective novel in his high school days, leading to the famous novelist and literary critic Tetsuya Ayukawa (real name Toru Nakagawa) publishing his stories under the Honkakusuiri anthologies of detective novels published between 1993 and 2009. Sure, his interest is in the veins of Edogawa Ranpo's Shonen Detective Agency and the ever-so-popular Conan Doyle's Sherlock Holmes series, and it's only until his graduation from the Tokyo Jikei University School of Medicine that he started to write novels earnestly, which saw many of his later works being published, some even nominated and winning awards. Interestingly, the accolades didn't include his most prized notary work, Ameku Takao no Suiri Karte, for which the novel is still in serialization since September 2014.
But back to Ameku Takao, it's clear that Mikito Chinen was inspired by the likes of Doctor-X: Surgeon Michiko Daimon and (especially) the predominance of American hospital/medical dramas like House M.D. to create his own derivative of Dr. Gregory House and his small group of friends, as seen by the titular character of Takao Ameku and her host of contacts in the hospital environment they reside in, full of investigative wonders and medical cases that she can only solve when others cannot.
The titular MC being the director of the Department of Investigative Pathology at Tenikai General Hospital, don't ever underestimate her chibi size for someone easy to be stepped on, because aside from her lucrative role, she is the vice-chairman of the hospital alongside her uncle Owashi, though both cousins always have the "agree to disagree" counterintuitive arguments that never seem to end, with Owashi thinking that she's wasting her time with a department that only specializes in medical scenarios where no case can be diagnosed by any other physician in the hospital. Naturally, the rift between cousins forces Takao to isolate herself, as seen by the weird brick house on the hospital's rooftop, which also serves as her residing office, visited by the people that are closest to her. The first of which is her closest assistant, Yu Takanashi, the man who's always being chided by Takao most of the time under her whims and is the main support of her investigative detective mystery-solving adventures enough for her to nickname him Kotori a.k.a. birdbrain, alongside ER nurse Mai Konoike and her own caring older sister Mazuru. On the police's end, you have the detectives Ryuuya Naruse and Kimiyasu Sakurai, who are always coming into contact with Takao should she need their help when it comes to the mysterious deaths and murders. And they all have to work together like a well-oiled machine because it's their careers on the line that they face judgment of if wrong assumptions are made that result in the outcome of the deaths of the people they're involved with.
I've consistently seen that the one criticism of the series in general is how superlative it feels against the sightings of the cases that Takao got herself into. Be it the medical diagnoses or the detective mysteries, it just doesn't have that realism that's rooted in the "true" Sherlock Holmes style, or that the medical cases are not supervised stringently, considering the workload of the doctors and nurses in typical hospitals. But then again, you have to remember that this is fiction (with the notion of the disclaimers in the episode openings), and the medical drama that goes into it may seem juxtaposed and contrary to real-life operations, but that's the reality of most medical drama-centric series: you can "fake it till you make it", however, medical prescriptions, diseases, and the like still have to sound real enough to induce the drama that comes out from it. It's a thing just to bring out the drama; some will love it, others will hate it, plain and simple.
Admittedly, any production under Aniplex will suffer in the long term, as is Project No. 9 here, with clearly flailing animation that gets worse as the series progresses with its fervent delays and such. It's not the best; it's serviceable at best, but you will certainly see the degradation in quality. To be fair, Loop 7-kaime a.k.a. 7th Time Loop director Kazuya Iwata tried his best, but the circumstances speak for themselves here.
The OST is also decent, though I really didn't notice much of it composed by Fox Capture Plan. At least Aimer's OP song is solid, as is The Gospellers with their ED song alongside Anly.
This is a reality that's harder to swallow, but if you're expecting House M.D. vibes from this, you've come to the wrong place. Against the "genius" that is Takao Ameku, it's clear that Mikito Chinen was hoping to marry both the medical and detective segments together and make it work; the only problem is that the arcs (at least within the anime) can feel like they were played with a fiddle, or just enough medical advice is instilled to the point where it "feels" believable (of course, not forgetting that this is still fiction after all).
Whatever the case profile is, just go into Ameku Takao no Suiri Karte a.k.a. Ameku M.D.: Doctor Detective, not thinking that you'll come out a whizz in medical proficiency but rather, savouring a show that is just alright and for the dramaticization purposes alone.
bossunhimeswitch
I found out about this show when someone mentioned an anime Dr. House, and the show definitely lived up to that description and surpassed my expectations based on it. I liked that it was less cynical than it could have been and that the mysteries were interesting. That said, I think that there was a genericness to it that prevented it from being an 8/10 for me even though I did enjoy it especially for the characters. If you enjoy detective shows and don't mind medical shows, then you'll enjoy this anime. If you do not enjoy depictions of immolation, watching people die, and medicalprocedures, then this is an anime to skip.
ATP_Synthase
The whole plot feels a lot like House MD, but instead of an old grumpy man, we get an arrogant, tiny anime girl! I haven’t watched much of House MD, but this anime is mostly focused on murder mysteries. As someone who is somewhat well-versed in human physiology and medicine, I found it fairly enjoyable. I liked trying to figure out the mysteries and the crazy situations using only the limited information provided. I also love Takao’s character design. However, I feel like in some cases, the show deliberately hides key information or gives misleading clues, making it impossible to figure out what’s going on beforeTakao reveals it. That said, since I don’t usually watch mystery or detective anime/shows, this felt fresh to me. For others, it might just be another detective show with a small medical twist.
yama8
The amount of hate this series is getting is frankly quite baffling, this is a good series for viewers that want intelligent content and proper story writing. Ameku Takao no Suiri Karte is actually a pretty underrated mix of mystery and medical drama. It follows Dr. Ameku, an intelligent but eccentric doctor who solves strange medical cases. Think of it like a mix between Sherlock and Dr. House—cold, blunt, but insanely sharp. Each case is short and easy to get into, with just the right amount of medical details. It helps that the author has a medical doctorate/practicising doctor, so the medical stuff checks out. Myonly critique is that Ameku’s partner or rather her apprentice, Dr. Kusaka, is not well fleshed out enough - but still a decent sidekick (who is able to physically fight and isnt a wimp)
Personally, the cases are interesting enough to keep you hooked. The writing stays really solid and the mysteries are satisfying. Great for fans of clever, episodic stories with a unique lead.
RomanRonin
Ameku M.D is Sherlock Holmes + House combined into a singular, tsundere anime girl. The premise is simple: a genius doctor investigates and solves unsolvable forensic mysteries. Most of the time, these kinds of shows falter because the writers, being human after all, aren't at the same level as the geniuses they're trying to depict. While there's still a little bit of that in here, Dr. Takao is actually pretty well written. Everything she says sounds far-fetched, until you look it up and it actually is the case. Obviously there's a lot of anime logic for these kinds of cases to pop up in suchfrequency in the first place, but it feels a lot better knowing that they're actually being addressed properly, and not by the magic wand of the writer's whims. This show is hard-carried by Dr. Takao, but Kotori, her equivalent to Dr. Watson, is also an interesting figure who meshes well with her personality. Admittedly though, the rest of the cast is somewhat undeveloped compared to these two, but that's okay considering the nature of this show isn't meant to revolve around a wide cast.
If I had to level a critique of this show, I'd say that these side characters can be a bit wonky at times. For instance, some characters get themselves implicated in greater crimes for stupid reasons, seemingly just to provide a red herring to the audience. But, even then, this is about what you'd expect for the format. If you like the idea of mysteries being broken down with logic, but are still willing to endure some anime logic for the enjoyment of the show, then this is worth the watch.
unkun
I think this anime was solid and was an interesting mystery anime. I would have given 8 if they didn't mess up their animation that terribly. This is a mystery anime and doesn't require high-quality animation but they have to put some effort into drawing. The character looked like some amateur artist drew. The animation was so bad I had a hard time focusing on the actual story and mystery. This anime was cool by mixing medical science and murder mystery and I would recommend it for people who like mystery. But this poor-quality animation gets to a point where you can't focus. If youare capable of not getting distracted by the poor animation, I think it is a decent anime to watch.
lilgapple
Ameku Takao no Suiri Karte is a mystery masked as a medical anime. If you love mysteries, you will surely enjoy this series. Each mystery is elegantly solved with medical terminology, making it a unique blend of genres that stands out. Don’t fret about the technical aspects—everything is explained in a way that keeps it enjoyable, even for those unfamiliar with medical jargon. The medical mysteries are fun while carrying serious undertones, which adds a layer of intrigue to each episode. Some of the mysteries have real stakes, think life and death, which heightens the tension and keeps you invested. There’s even a hint of romance betweenthe two main characters, stemming from their natural chemistry. It becomes increasingly obvious that they gradually end up caring deeply for each other, adding a subtle emotional thread to the story.
The side characters are important to the mysteries as well; they’re not just there for show. Their involvement enhances the narrative and gives the mysteries more depth, making them feel integral to the plot rather than mere background filler.
What makes this show stand out from ordinary mystery anime is that each mystery is unpredictable in a good way. However, each mystery remains independent, with no overarching connection to the others. While this keeps the episodes self-contained, one criticism is that tying them together could bring more depth to a potential holistic plot.
If you enjoyed Odd Taxi, or even Shoshimin: How to Become Ordinary I think you would sincerely enjoy this anime. If mysteries are not your thing but dramas are I would still recommend giving this anime a shot.
GalacticWeiss12
If you want an anime that will be looked at as an underrated gem, may not get a lot of talk, or overall an anime that you would recommend to someone for a first time or just out of your love for this anime. Amaeku Takao is the one for you to recommend to others. This is an anime that really did a great job of having some two partners for a twelve episodes run. I find it really well executed and at times wished more animes would take this two part route with certain aspects. It did not feel rushed, did notinterject the main characters having love interests, nor did it have to delve into comedy to make it suffer as well. I overall found that the tone for this anime was set pretty early, with a serious main character who while she seems perfect had her flaws and that was well done.
It never made me angry, but the best part of this anime is seeing how some victims are either redeemable or not redeemable depending on the circumstance of said cases.
psyched_ew
What if Dr. House and Sherlock Holmes had a love child, and that child grew up diagnosing rare diseases in Japan while simultaneously uncovering criminals? Welcome to the over-the-top, doctor-by-day, detective-by-night world of Ameku Takao no Surui Karute, where medical drama meets Scooby-Doo. The show absolutely delivers what it promises: wild, unpronounceable diseases diagnosed on gut instinct by a small, yappy doctor with a slight god complex — and diagnostic methods that range somewhere between actual medicine and anime-tier clairvoyance. Half the time you’re not sure if you’re watching a hospital drama or a supernatural mystery. Ameku Takao and her team almost always manage to uncover some hiddenclue and solve each case in ways you’d never think possible.
I now fear sneezing in public — Ameku might diagnose me with a rare Amazonian fungus and find out I jaywalked in 2009.
Will it blow you away with some insane story or long-developing character arcs? No.
Is it some emotionally draining drama? Also no (minus maybe two episodes that kind of were).
But is it supposed to be either of those things? No — and that’s a good thing.
Ameku M.D. is 12 episodes of fun, fast-paced, and surprisingly watchable entertainment that blends the best of both medical and detective worlds.
Final diagnosis: 8/10. If you need something light, bingeable, and funny, this is the place to go.
rjhtml
This anime lacks direction. Its house meets CSI meets ancient aliens. Also the main character beyond arrogant, narcissist, and infuriating. She has no regard for her actions and the consequences that it might generate, she pretty much insufferable as possible. she nor the rest of the characters exhibit any sort of growth. For example, the main character is said to look like a child but gets irritated when she's reminded of that, however the way she acts never dissuade you of that notion. JUST BECAUSE SOMEONE IS A GENIUS DOES NOT MAKE THEM ALL KNOWING. They should have just kept it to a medicalanime.
luxray978
__Background on me__ In a vacuum, Dr. Ameku ticks so many of my boxes for my personal interests. The medical aspect is super engaging for me as someone who is a former pre-med and is still working in biomedical science. As well I love detective stories and try to watch all that release each season. Needless to say, I really wanted Dr. Ameku to be great but I think it falls short of that as I’ll lay out in this review. __Animation/Visual style__ The visual style is nothing special, with functional animation lacking a lot of flair. The most notable visual element is the closeups ofmoving objects like Dr. Ameku's record player used occasionally, which are a good mixup. I saw a lot of complaints online about long pans during dialogue scenes, but they didn’t personally stick out to me. This may be because I was focused on reading subtitles and thinking through the mystery and it probably is more apparent to a Japanese or dubbed viewer.
__Plot and mysteries:__
First of all, there isn’t an overarching plot to Dr. Ameku which is typical of the detective genre and fine. I personally prefer when there’s a loose connection between cases or something overarching to chase after but it’s all a matter of opinion. However, I will note that they also lack any overarching theme or analysis across the cases which I think is a missed opportunity to add depth.
The lack of consistency alluded to earlier is one of my largest issues with the show and it can be seen in their quality and topic choice. It gyrates between house-style in-hospital medical mysteries and out-of-hospital detective dramas with a medical flair. I think in a vacuum this is a cool idea to add variety to the series, but it often feels like the two concepts are crowding themselves out and one has to take the backseat. As far as the writing of the Mysteries, they range from very simple to decently fleshed out, which can create a weird mental feeling. This becomes especially frustrating when they show an easy clue repeatedly on screen far after the point where the audience has got the idea. This choice in certain scenes is made even more odd by how the show is at other times extremely good at subtly conveying medical information through body language or a well-indicated background detail. This feels great when you notice it before the reveal and can gloat to yourself that you put that together.
__Character Design:__
The character design iThe character design doesn't stand out, like the animation, with the exception of Dr. Ameku who feels unique and vibrant compared to the rest of the cast. The other standout is the Columbo-looking detective who I can’t help but really enjoy. There are some clashing designs such as a doctor in the last mystery with strange massive eyes but it's not common.
__Characters:__
Side characters have their motivations plausably shown but I didn’t find myself compelled by their stories. They do a passable job of giving contextualizing the case but it's usually nothing more. Of the main cast, Dr. Ameku is by far the most interesting, with her inability to control her emotions and tsundere demeanor. I really wish the show had spent more time giving her opportunities to display this because it's a very strong aspect and is fun to watch. Her aide Kotori works as a narrative device and as a straight man but is often flat. His biggest hits come from how he changes a little bit over the series and whenever there is relational tension with Dr. Ameku. Like Dr. Ameku's emotions, I wish they had developed their relationship a bit more actively as I think there is some interesting potential for tension in his caretaker vs student vs romantic (?) dynamic.
__Treatment of women/minorities:__
The depiction of autism is very engaging and conveys an interesting dynamic but is undercut by how Dr. Ameku is infantilized. She's depicted struggling to engage with social dynamics, sitting strangely, failing to sit still, and having issues interacting with others. This part is really good even especially when she talks about how her struggles make her feel. However, at the same time, it's made fraught by the choice to depict a __27-year-old woman__ as looking like a child. It unfortunately feeds into the long history of high-functioning autistic and women people being treated like they aren’t adults. I find this difficult to get a pulse on because this “moe” aspect is part of the reason a lot of people come to shows like Dr. Ameku, but it often makes me pretty uncomfortable. It’s possible this is an intentional decision to pair her “childlike” actions with a more suiting form but if that’s the case I think it’s a bit of a cop-out. To me, it would be more intellectually interesting to see the discontinuity of Dr. Ameku’s actions in an adult body as done for male genius detectives.
As far as everyone else, other women are all portrayed in a strictly average way with all the positives and negatives of normal Japanese societal expectations.
__Conclusion:__
In conclusion, Dr. Ameku is a series with a very interesting premise that often falls short of its potential. For people who like mysteries and medicine stories, this is a must-watch only because you are unlikely to find anything else like it. However, for everyone else I find this to be a much harder show to recommend and I’m going to leave my final score as a 7/10.
whiteflame55
Hey, it’s House M.D. with a loli in the lead role. Sure it was kind of derivative, but a medical mystery anime isn’t terribly common. Of course, one of the few examples just so happened to be airing this season in The Apothecary Diaries, a series that already had a lot of steam going with substantial worldbuilding and a palace intrigue plot to boot. However, I’m not here to compare. What makes this series special? It features a lot of modern medicine and remains relatively realistic throughout. I say “relatively” because the first case involves a man with blue blood having his leg bitten off bya Tyrannosaurus Rex skeleton and a later one involves spontaneous combustion, but most of the mysteries in here are more grounded. There’s even one I was able to puzzle out before the titular Ameku could do it. Nice to see that Microbiology PhD is paying off. Even the more outlandish cases have a certain allure to them, basically dragging you by the nose to the end just to see how it all comes together.
And it’s not just grounded in its mysteries, but occasionally in its drama. Ameku spends a substantial arc dealing with the realities of a child dying of cancer, someone she formed a relationship with but abandoned to isolate herself emotionally from the reality that she can’t save everyone. It’s not exactly a deep emotional journey and I’ve seen it explored better in a single episode of Scrubs (“My Super Ego,” well worth the watch).
The animation is pretty good throughout. They do a surprisingly haunting job with the flames in this series and many of the visuals really pop, particularly in the OP.
Unfortunately, that’s about all I’ve got for the positives.
While this series does get some of the basics of House M.D. right (a genius doctor who does his own thing to save the lives of his patients, often flouting rules), it spends a lot more time dealing with forensic science than actual medicine, more often dealing with cases where someone has died and trying to find the killer. It’s not a surprising turn, but it is disappointing, as the show becomes more a series of murder mysteries than anything else, and we’ve got plenty of those in anime.
What makes that more frustrating is that its mysteries aren’t things you can figure out by looking at a crime scene. You have to have the necessary medical knowledge to be able to put together information at the scene with diagnostics, which means that unless you have a very technical set of expertise, you’re not resolving any of these mysteries (much less the more convoluted ones mentioned above) before or at the same time as Ameku. Mystery shows can still work OK if you can’t predict what’s going to happen, but part of what makes a great mystery is being able to put the pieces together. If this was just a medical mystery, it might be interesting to just watch them puzzle these things out based on a variety of test results and analysis, but we’re solving crimes here as well and it feels like a large part of that is just a giant shrug and “leave it to Ameku to figure this out.”
None of this is helped by having a lead character who just isn’t Gregory House. To be clear, I wasn’t looking for a carbon copy of House in loli form, but I was looking for a character who had more personality than this. House is interesting in part because he’s got a lot of problems and is generally abrasive to everyone, including his patients and staff, all of which barely conceals a lot of damage in his past and present. By contrast, Ameku just isn’t much more than a very self-confident young doctor with a complex about being called small who struggles with the deaths of her patients and doesn’t understand the word “no.” It’s not exactly a distinctive character archetype in anime, and it wouldn’t stand out among a sea of medical mystery dramas in live action. Really, the only thing that seems to distinguish her is the almost “mind palace”-like deductions she does while sketching out connections with her fingers, both of which heavily evoke Sherlock Holmes… and as someone who has gotten very frustrated with how much mystery series lean on the legendary detective, this did not help my perception of Ameku as a distinctive character.
It’s not like this series doesn’t have interesting ideas, either. That’s part of the problem: it knows how to do a good medical mystery drama, it just doesn’t spend a lot of its time doing it. There’s a short mystery involving a child and their mother that was particularly interesting to follow and did, in many ways, feel like an actual episode of House M.D. An episode involving the excavation of a tomb and the belief in a resultant curse (before the fires start) wasn’t too far off, either, even if it did feel a bit extra. It’s just a shame that these feel more like the exceptions rather than the rules, with each of them spanning single episodes while other mysteries cover multiple episodes. And the split between these and the more over-the-top-crazy mysteries didn't help. It ended up doing the worst of both worlds: never feeling so absurd that you could just turn your brain off and roll with the crazy, nor so grounded that you could really get into the mysteries and how the characters explore them.
Even the final little arc, which brings some personal stakes back to Ameku and Takanashi’s doorstep, feels like it puts an arbitrary and weird time limit on an investigation for something that doesn’t feel all that heavily consequential after watching the series tackle so many cases of death and near-death, though they certainly try to sell it as more. Adding a ticking clock to a mystery can sometimes work, but it didn’t work here.
There are good ideas in here that I can see absolutely working out for the better over a broader span of episodes with more diverse mysteries. It’s just a shame that so much of this feels so humdrum with a cast of characters that are fine and mysteries that average out to fine without ever really pushing the strengths this series should have in spades.
clio_selene
I enjoyed this anime more than I'd expected. I'm not a fan of detective stories, and, as a physician myself, I approach any medical fiction with caution since they often contain terrible mistakes etc. However, as I give lectures about how medical staff is portrayed in manga & anime, I had to watch "Ameku Takao" too. I'm extremely satisfied with how the medical stuff is showed in Ameku. It's simply reliable, starting from proper CPR tempo. It also gives us some view on the personalities and simply lives of people who work in health care: we see that they are humans, too, and suffer, struggle, despair.Furthermore, as a psychiatrist, I'm deeply delighted with the main character and her neuropsychiatric traits (among all, Asperger syndrome) that is fantastically portrayed without giving it a name: for example, Ameku suffers from oversensitivity and considers herself unable to normally interact with other people. And she indeed often speak her mind without considering others, is honest to a fault, orders people when she sees it right etc. Then there is her genius, her obsessiveness about finding the right answer, her incredible memory and logical skills that make her the best diagnostician there. It all should be attributed to her neuropsychiatric disorder. She is at times unnerving, overreacting or simply rude, but she is definitely being herself.
I also enjoyed watching Ameku and Kotori's relationship and how they clumsily care about each other. It's obvious that Kotori gives Ameku irreplaceable support by unconditionally accepting her and still correcting her when needed, and she is aware of it. When watching, I was touched by their interactions but also interaction with others. I also found some of the cases really moving.
All in all, I'm glad that I decided to watch "Ameku Takao" because it gave me a positive surprise and some emotional moments. If you would like to watch anime with properly showed medical stuff and an interesting MC with reliably portrayed neuropsychiatric disorder, I recommend this to you.
johInAwe
This work presents a very engaging collection of stories which could be binge watched but, to my taste, might provide a better viewing experience when spaced in blocks (especially as the stories from the second 3rd of the show onwards get split into double/triple episodes). While character development and good storytelling are present, there is not much of a plot to be developed outside of the Dr. House-esque premise. Takao manages to be even better of a tsundere than House himself, which suits the title’s biggest strength: its main cast. As far as world building goes, the remaining storytelling features tend to take place through predictable formulasor shallow applications - to put it in perspective, it feels like both the medic & mystery tropes are better explored in Apothecary Diaries which aired at the same time. While this didn’t lead to a poor viewing experience, the better stories (subjective) stand out significantly as a result.
On the other hand, production leaves less to be desired, offering a lot of value as the main cast’s powerful voice acting and great design make for most of Ameku M.D.'s runtime.
In conclusion, Ameku M.D.: Doctor Detective is a very light-hearted show that can spark intense emotions like a proper drama would. To my understanding, the show doesn’t lean too heavily on the mystery label which is something to be mindful of in terms of setting expectations.
edamott
Ameku Takao no Suiri Karte earns an 8/10. Its unique approach lies in Dr. Takao's sharp diagnostic deductions, making the case solving process the engaging core, even if the medical mystery setup isn't entirely new. The clean art style perfectly fits the clinical yet intriguing atmosphere. Takao herself is presented as exceptionally intelligent, which is her main strength; character reactions generally feel appropriate for the situations presented within the show's logic. The fantastic OP is a definite plus! While the story starts strong, the ending, despite maintaining intrigue, felt somewhat less satisfying. Recommended for mystery fans seeking clever problem solving; others will likely enjoy Takao'sunique deductive methods for a good watch.
patkarunungan
'Ameku M.D.: Doctor Detective' is one of the Winter 2025 I really enjoyed. It's basically a mystery show where the detective is a medical doctor and incidentally an attractive woman. For some reason, I like this better than the Apothecary Diaries and some prefer the Apothecary Diaries over this. The problem with the Apothecary Diaries is that it starts slow and boring until, just as in the case of Season 1, the individual arcs come together in the second cour, which is what I expect will happen in this second season. 'Doctor Detective' detective is solely focused on the mysteries. Indeed, the Apothecary Diaries is thesuperior story and rewards the patient viewer, but 'Doctor Detective' gives you an immediate payoff. It's just 2 or 3 episodes to deal with a particular case.
(As a side note, the story is not unique. It has been compared repeatedly to the US series House M.D., which I haven't seen. Coincidentally, there's a kdrama titled 'Doctor Detective' but isn't really a direct inspiration because there's no single doctor let alone a beautiful lady as the lead protagonist.)
Doctor Detective's weakness is its seeming lack of plot. Each arc could've been re-arranged in any order without affecting the continuity of the story. If there's any semblance of plot here, it's the seemingly budding romance between Ameku Takao and 'Kotori,' which is not explored this season. Hence, the finale feels like a good but hollow conclusion of the arc instead of something that builds up from Episode 1.
Another weakness is the choice of mystery, and this may be a big deal if you're trying to actively predict the solution to the mystery. Solving it requires medical knowledge, and a viewer without medical knowledge might only predict in broad strokes, if at all, but not the specific medical condition.
The musick in this anime is great. Aimer's OP is a banger. The Gospellers and Anly's ED sounds bittersweet. Again, it's not part of my consideration but it's part of the package.
The visuals are great. I like the sequence whenever Takao-sensei gains an insight.
Regardless of the weaknesses I mentioned above, it's still an enjoyable watch and I'm giving it a 7.
olokinprime
The main character, Takao Ameku, the childlike doctor and genius diagnostician, is a less crochety House and a less drugged up Holmes, all packaged as a petite anime girl. Basically, ingredients for peak postmodern fiction. The animation was sleek and above average. The voice acting work from the cast was on character and enhanced the storytelling. Of personal importance was a main character with a postgraduate degree, which implied at least post college age, and it had a mystery afoot, qualities I look in an anime for my age group. The main character is a genius, but no Mary Sue, as she had her vulnerabilities exploredin an excellent 2-episode arc. She made mistakes too, a genius that was humanly grounded.
So, if you have aged beyond the high school setting and main characters of most anime series, I highly recommend this anime that featured a main cast of working adults. The anime had above average production values, so the visual quality was pleasant. There's always a mystery to be solved, which detective story buffs would appreciate. Really though, all the reason you need to watch is that this is House as an anime girl.
This was my 69th review on this platform, so it was indeed nice.
IoremIpsum12
Story We meet again with anime where female detective and male secretary with the premise as a doctor, for the initial premise actually this is a bit interesting where we solve a murder case or social event with a doctor's point of view, there are some interesting cases in my opinion like we solve murder with supernatural pretext with scientific demeanor from a doctor, although honestly every case is interesting there are also weak ones like the case of a high school student who has epilepsy or a child who has cancer which in my opinion this episode is not suitable to be brought in adetective series like this because it feels like it only wants to attract the audience's heart. the rest of the cases brought are not too bad but that doesn't mean the whole thing is good.
Character
Ameku is an interesting character and dominates the show even though for some reason her knowledge is not in line with her personality as seen in the episode when her patient died, this slightly lowered my expectations for her because previously she had solved the murder case, besides that for the supporting role of Takanashi, her role is not too helpful like most female detective anime and her character design is not too interesting and also the supporting roles such as Kounike and Mazuru, Ameku's brother, are not told much and in my opinion the most fatal thing about this anime is the role of the original detective Sakurai who really has very little impact on the murder case which actually feels like she only obeys Ameku who is a doctor rather than herself who is a police detective.
Visual
This is the worst thing about this show, maybe some of you feel that this series has a good visual design but if you look again behind the good visual design there is a bad animation visual, like in episode 10 you will see a lot of broken and inconsistent transitions like when my ame is having a dialogue but the visual displayed is a doorknob or window and it is displayed 2 to 3 times and this also happens in all episodes when the dialogue displayed is objects from the case which are displayed several times rather than when the person is having the dialogue.
Personal enjoyment
My expectations were too high when I watched episode 1 of this anime, it would actually be an interesting anime if it really got a deeper characterization execution in terms of storytelling and animation, it was very hard to watch episodes 6-12 especially episodes 8-10 which I think are not suitable for a detective anime like this and instead only exist to attract the audience's hearts to feel sad, this anime will be good if you watch it when you really have free time and don't expect more.
Supersonic_Pain
Tbh, this gave me really strong vibes of the anime equivalent of watching, like, NCIS or Law and Order: SVU (or whatever the medical equivalent of that is... I guess it'd be Chicago Med?). Just something you have on to have on, you know? I've heard it compared to House MD a lot and as someone who has never seen House, I wouldn't be able to tell you, but it is a medically-focused detective show. And it's pretty unremarkable. Any character that isn't the titular Takao might as well not exist because they're pretty unmemorable. I thought Mai (the other female nurse who is supposedly a gal despitebeing, like, one shade darker than Takao) would be a part of the main cast but she barely matters and is never like officially part of the gang, anyone but Takao and Takanashi are only useful so far as their parts in the story, it is a two character cast and really, Takanashi's only there as The Straight Man so the waifu of the show can shine.
I thought Takao was entertaining enough, I guess, although she's a pretty stock standard QuIrKy character. Despite being a doctor, she doesn't like her vegetables! Breathtaking.
Something about the artstyle was not clicking with me. The presentation as a whole is kind of dry although the "eureka" moment is one of the worst examples I've ever seen. The brain blast is whatever but the song they picked is godawful and sounds like someone trying out a new beatmaking system not knowing anything about music theory. Not to mention Takao "tracing" in the sky along with that... just ugh.
Aimer cooked with the OP tho, did she know she was making this for Ameku MD: Doctor Detective?
How are the mysteries?
I think this is part of the problem with the show. Since it's centered around medical mysteries, you either have to pick from a handful of diagnoses the average anime watcher would know or you just say fuck it and let your medical knowledge shine and have the anime viewers just kind of passively, helplessly watch on, not even being able to guess what thing you're gonna pull out of a medical textbook.
I kind of figured out a couple of them knowing a little bit of medical stuff but, say, the first mystery (which is where the show peaks but still)? Fuck if I know, man. The last mystery was kind of pissing me off because it was Ace Attorney-level kangaroo court (as much as I like that series) where the police detective could've had Jesus Christ himself laser beam proof that the defendant didn't do it and he's like "erm, well, who DID do it then?"
You're really only here for the (hit or miss) mysteries and Takao herself, there's not much else to see here. The only time it made me actually feel something is when there was literally just a child dying of cancer.
If you want to watch medically-oriented detective cases, it is a perfectly decent watch. Do not feel like you have to go out of your way to watch this though.
