In the newly formed Shiniki district of Tokyo, Zen Seizaki is a diligent public prosecutor at the Tokyo District Public Prosecutors Office. Assigned to a case involving false advertisement, Zen—along with his assistant officer, Atsuhiko Fumio—investigate Japan Supiri, a pharmaceutical company that had provided fabricated clinical research on the company's new drug. While investigating the file of Shin Inaba, an anesthesiologist connected to the crime, the case takes a dark turn when Zen finds a page stained with a mixture of blood, hair and skin, along with the letter "F" scribbled all across the sheet. As he investigates further, the case goes beyond Zen's imagination and becomes vastly complex, challenging his sense of justice and his knowledge of the truth.
Digging deeper into the investigation, Zen begins to uncover a concealed plot behind the ongoing mayoral election and ties to many people of interest involved in the election and those closer than he thinks. The case grows more severe and propels Zen into an unforeseen hurricane of corruption and deceit behind the election, the establishment of the Shiniki district, and the mysterious woman associated with it all.
[Written by MAL Rewrite]
Nenhum episódio encontrado.
Comentários
SpikyTurtle
Review contains some spoilers: This is going to be a short review/rant about Babylon. I remember when the first 3 episodes came out everyone was impressed since this show had amazing cinematography and direction, a dark and thrilling atmosphere and the story was executed seemingly very well. It continued to be quite good until the 7th episode, then it had a long break and everything went to shit. Babylon would have been great if if was just a political thriller with mystery elements. But the suicide law going worldwide and the law in general ruined the show. It is just very unrealistic that people would react to thislaw in such a way (similar laws already exist), the politicians are portrayed very poorly and every decision made in the 2nd half of the show just makes no sense. The discussion that occured in the summit was portrayed as "deep" although it really wasn't, politicians should leave philosophy for actual famous and talented philosophers. Magase is obviously the actual danger, that can bring doom to humanity, but she became just a subplot for most of the 2nd half.
The main aspect of this show - the suicide law just fails as a plot point, since it really doesn't matter because Magase Ai can just persuade literally anyone to kill themselves.
All in all, at the start this show seemed quite profound and well-executed, but really it was pretentious, extremely unrealistic and absurd. My and many people's expectations were shattered by this show, but I'd still recommend watching the first 7 episodes. One or two eps were pretty exceptional, therefore I'm giving Babylon the rating of 3/10 - overall it's a really bad show, but has a few remarkable moments.
SingleH
This review is best consumed pretending you hadn’t just seen the score it’s headed with. This one’s going to be real prosaic, because Babylon is a very dense, logically tight show for adults in a way you don’t often see in media, especially anime, and is certainly not for people even among older audiences who cannot keep up with sociopolitical factions and legal jargon, as it is a premiere example of a political thriller, a genre both elusive in the medium and almost never laudably delivered on therein or out. Every facet of the show is oozing with a thick sense of seriousness and often boils downto a lot of very grave talk amongst crotchety middle-aged politicians and civil servants trying to solve real crime, all of which is presented without a lick of fun or funniness. It’s exciting simply because it operates on the very generous assumption you, the viewer, are mature and worldly enough to recognize the implications of what’s happening in the story are really serious in a hyper-realistic fashion, and the fact the world is established such that that sense of realism is actually believable, the events play out like urgent breaking news as opposed to the writings of an inherently fictitious narrative. Where Babylon becomes something of a masterwork, though, is in its functionality as a mystery. Like any good political thriller, Babylon is rife with juicy machinations behind the scenes and moving parts to obfuscate them, but unlike most so-called mystery box narratives which string you along offering nothing but minuscule and minute information only at times convenient for the writers—which you could’ve very well gotten at any moment—until it’s all over and the contents of the box turn out to be ultimately unsatisfying, Babylon continually gives you specific and totally gratifying answers to questions you have, thusly reassuring you of the show’s ability to deliver on its promises, and packaged within those answers lie details of an even large mystery to come to light, so—at the same time—you’re fulfilled momentarily whilst continually intrigued with what the hell else is going on. And while Babylon opens itself with the heavy task of untangling this mess of clues and conclusions, the reason the situation is so complicated is every player is operating of their own accord, so whilst the narrative is never dizzyingly convoluted, it is very complex, even though it soon reveals itself to be one of the shows which has you slowly realize less of it is actually a conspiracy than you may’ve first thought.
Babylon takes place in the city of Shiniki, the self-proclaimed testing ground for nations, a special administrative zone just north of Tokyo who's mission statement is to decentralize the Japanese economic center away from the overburdened Tokyo metroplex while also instating a new city with little regulation where laws are both easy to pass and easy to terminate, hence the tagline. Our main character, Seizaki Zen, is a public prosecutor who finds himself investigating a string of apparently related incidents of political sex trafficking being used to influence elections in the city, and it doesn’t take long for him and the viewer to come to the cold realization these cases are merely the tip of the iceberg of a thoroughly deep rooted scandal, which is to say—minor spoilers from here on—the police are in cahoots with the corrupt politicians. As Seizaki is lured into the conspirators' camp by the fact they’re work rigging elections is actually—no matter how rigorously illegal their actions are—for the greater good of stabilizing Shiniki’s still shaky political sphere and finally giving the city an identity of its own as the aforementioned legal envelope pusher, the puppet candidate they’re working to instate in office suddenly cuts ties with his fellow conspirators the second he’s elected and announces—unbeknownst to them and in complete and utter surprise to all their plans—his first new law to define the courageous new world which this city was always meant to be: the Suicide Law, the right to kill yourself. And what follows is the single most cinematically genius use of mass media spectacle I’ve seen in any anime ever. The already blood pumping, philosophically stimulating narrative of Babylon proceeds by stacking plot twists in such a way you’re constantly shocked, with every episode having some element which radically changes your perception of the events so far, all while the scale of said narrative keeps widening and widening, with every conversation adding some kind of information and the scripting continuously parceling out information in such a way which is integral to the storytelling’s engrossing identity, keeping us viewers absolutely intoxicated.
Itsuki Kaika, the upstart mayor heading the Suicide Law, was chosen by the conspiring faction to be the puppet leader because of his young and refreshing image first and foremost, but also because he personally brought in the women they used to influence policy with sex and set their entire initiative into motion in the first place. As the conspirators in the challenging political parties and police headquarters, now including Seizaki, have to deal with their rouge masterless puppet, Seizaki is let in on some of the secrets they’d been keeping from him from when he was in the dark, one of which being the sinister fact all the women they’d been trafficking—including one sugar baby he himself had interrogated when previously working the case—was actually one person, one person named Magase Ai. As the show continues on and the narrative undergoes paradigm shift after paradigm shift, it quickly becomes apparent Magase Ai is much more urgent a threat than Itsuki ever was and is also hinted to even have some enigmatic occult afflictions. And before you turn away thinking a supernatural twist would ruin a straight-faced and thickly realistic narrative, remember plot devices as genius as The Voice of the City from Texhnolyze or The Black Blob from Paranoia Agent and remind yourself magical realism can be instated smartly into serious and mature stories. I’ll stop spoiling things now hoping my hinting at this character is motivation enough to go watch the show yourself, because she is a case study on presence and easily among the most electric personalities ever put to animation and says some thematically profound things about the nature of femininity and the allure and logical extreme of sexual release. And speaking of animation, her character design is iconic, her theme is enchanting, and again, her presence is simply immense. With that said, while I’m at it, the show as a whole is quite something from a production standpoint itself. The aesthetics are not particularly appealing, and the animation isn’t consistently beautiful or anything, but if it was trying to look like a hyper-realistic human narrative taking place in the real world, it succeeded wholeheartedly. It boasts god tier music which was absolutely nail biting at times, and it staffed talented character animators like Kouki Fujimoto who delivered on the most thrilling breaking points of the story with all due flair and terror. And all this isn’t even going into the excellent and outright laudably ambitious directing fit with more memorable imagery and exquisitely shot visual metaphors than you could ever ask for. Honestly, any way you slice it, Babylon is something of a modern masterpiece.
… … …
In Spring of 2017, an original anime by the name of Seikaisuru Kado went to air. It was a modest little thing, at least on production, made by Toei Animation, the premiere home for long running Saturday Morning Cartoon shlock and pandering game adaptations. My crude and irrelevant derision aside, though, Seikaisuru Kado not only looks and feels nothing like a project out of Toei, but it also looks and feels quite like nothing I’ve ever seen before for many reasons. Be it the quasi-CG character animation production, the irreplaceably unique concepts to accompany an alien invasion, or the hundred-ton dialogue scripting swamped in international relations of all things, Seikaisuru Kado was certainly a diamond in the rough, even if a thoroughly, thoroughly, thoroughly unpolished one. While it fashioned far more comedic relief and character emotions than necessary for a work of its apparent type—unlike Babylon wherein the characters are mature adults who are taking the story very seriously at all times—Seikaisuru Kado was first and foremost a fairly smart, talkative narrative of political intrigue. To avoid alienating what little of you are still reading by further narrating a show you’re not here to learn about, I’ll sum up the experience by saying it was brilliant…for six episodes…then it was annoying for the following two…and then it was a corpse by the end of episode nine. It was intelligently structured and adherent to reality even amongst all its inane sci-fi concepts, and it kept building itself until by even halfway though I was ready to tout it as a downright intellectual giant. However, it soon began devolving under the surface, and sooner later snapped like a twig in the most bracing twist of quality in anime history. A more-than-average mature show about the advancement of humanity and international geopolitical negotiations behind such progress was put to death by the draw of a giant energy sworn swinging the story into a downwards spiral of over-the-top mindless action, aliens VS humans battle to the death, fucking daughter from the future, batshit anime insanity, and the entire merit of the work up until that point was squandered instantaneously. And its author…wrote Babylon.
At first, Babylon’s only real weakness was in the fact it attracts losers like myself. When you reach the stage of consumerism wherein your priorities become tone-deaf and your intentions become incorrigibly cynical, media—no matter how innocent in its attempts to entertain you—will find themselves endlessly, hopelessly, relentlessly attacked by your unconscious will to break something down, as you’ve conditioned your mind to be little more than a machine for critique which can only even begin to allow yourself an inch of entertainment from media which is totally infallible on every level, as you now know what it means to be so. And Babylon is not totally infallible. Babylon, much like Seikaisuru Kado, even before that heinous death blow the series dealt to itself which I just described, suffers from authorial projecting. That’s a nothing piece of terminology I just made up on the spot, but I mean it to imply exactly what it sounds like. Nozaki Mado, the creator of both works, quite frankly seems to fancy himself more of a preacher than a writer. His works so far have been bursting at the seems with unforgivingly unsubtle theming to the point of characters sitting down and spelling them out to the audience just to make sure his oh-so-precious point got across in the specific way he wanted it to. Honestly, as paradoxical as it sounds given the (periodic) maturity of his works, Nozaki seems to me to be thoroughly childish. Whereas the episodes wherein they do so and the degree to which they do so differ per show, both works reach a point around halfway through where the show takes all its ambivalent ideation and starts facing the audience directly and asserting these inherently subjective questions actually have objectively correct answers, because morals and God and shit. The works reach another turning point later on, though, towards the end, where the show completely shatters itself, and while, no, there is no giant energy sword in Babylon, the series does get to a point by the penultimate episode where anyone thinking at all critically simply has to put it down. That’s right. This masterpiece died young.
How anime which seem to so thoroughly understand the ways of the world lead themselves on with such delusions as evolutionary providence in Seikaisuru Kado and now a moral death in Babylon, I honestly will never know. I don’t get it, and now that we’re two for two with this guy, I frankly don’t even want to. Nozaki isn’t a writer the likes of Tow Ubukata, who hides the interworking of his concepts with an ostentatiously stylized exterior only to eventually expose their emptiness after its clear nothing is being said, nor is he like Shou Aikawa, who presents transparently style-over-substance codifications on behalf of potential themes which also end up being ultimately meaningless all the same. He presents concepts which do, indeed, payoff, and he continues to do so expertly, only for the process to devolve somewhere along the line and have the ideas stop churning out intellectual content and begin churning out holier than thou horse shit attempting to convince you of pretentiously figured objective answers to subjective moral questions. It’s like the latter ends of his works are written by an entirely different person with an entirely different set of priorities and personal values. On its way down from a thematically enormous wonder of a political thriller to a boilerplate pseudo-psychological character study, Babylon doesn’t break any one character, nor does it defile the established ideas, and it only really disrupts the tangible plot in the final episode and, I suppose, the cliffhanger leading into it. It only wastes itself in a general sense, so unlike Seikaisuru Kado who’s devolution wholly invalidates all merit it had accumulated up until the point the energy blade came out, Babylon is actually worth watching in a sense. In fact, you could probably just watch the first seven episodes as a complete story like all the brilliant bastards who dropped Death Note after episode twenty five. But do so knowing it continues. Know the following three and a half episodes slam on the breaks and attempt to convince you of the strict, objectivist take on the previously ambivalent, thought-provoking seven episode gem you just saw. And know, as well, the following episode and a half remaining after that turn out a finale which you’d never guess, not even in your wildest dreams, could ever have been derivative of the expert craft with which you began your viewing.
Thank you for reading.
Marinate1016
Every now and then a show comes along and has an absolutely amazing start, dazzles with great narrative, action, characters, etc and then it throws it all away at the end. Unfortunately, this is one of those. Babylon offers one of the most interesting examinations of the classic philosophical debate of Good vs Evil I have ever seen. While on paper, it’s easy for us to say what’s right and what’s wrong, in reality, it’s often much more difficult. Life is more often in shades of grey than black and white. Babylon does a really good job of making you question everything you thought youknew in terms of morality. Unfortunately, the show's premise goes by the wayside in one of the worst endings I have ever seen in anything.
The show deals with a recently passed legislation in a newly built city adjacent to Tokyo which legalises suicide. Unfortunately, not all of the people choosing to take advantage of this new law are doing so under their own will. Tokyo Prosecutor Zen Seizaki is tasked with investigating the cause of this movement and of several suspicious deaths and eventually finds himself involved in a philosophical and moral battle that’s bigger than he could have ever imagined.
Babylon doesn’t have much in the way of physical action in terms of fights, explosions, etc, so if you’re looking for that, this is not the show for you. What it makes up for it with is a mature story, absolutely masterful writing(first half), tension and direction that will consistently leave you on the edge of your seat, in my opinion, the greatest anime villain of all time (Magase) and challenging you to examine your own definition of morality.
The art is really well done and is quite unique in my opinion, the score is brilliant and adds a lot to the tension in scenes, the Voice acting is also top notch, particularly the work done by Yukino Satsuki(Magase). I will warn you that the tone of the show shifts quite dramatically after episode 7, there was a 6 WEEK break between episodes 7 and 8 which really killed a lot of the momentum of the show, and once the show resumed, the tone shifted from a fast paced detective thriller to a much more philosophical and narrative driven experience akin to End of Eva, which some people didn’t like, I personally enjoyed the shift initially, but things began to go south real soon.
Overall, Babylon started as one of my favourite shows of the year, and ended as one of the most disappointing I've ever seen. This was purely self inflicted damage. The author was on the cusp of greatness and let it slip, completely with an ending that is as nonsensical as they come.
I still would recommend giving this a watch, as I believe Magase is one of the best anime villains ever in terms of pure evil and being an unstoppable force. I also believe the first 7 episodes are some of the best you will see, just have tempered expectations for the finale.
Zerity
After just finishing Babylon I am honestly at a lost for words, this show is actually amazing and still love it after it's ending. It leaves you with many questions which are open to different interpretations depending on how you look at things. That is generally what a good mystery does, granted the first half was more intense and the second half went into a different approach focusing on another character but It was still as good. After thinking about the series for a bit I can't really find and complaints I had, it was interesting, raised themes which left me thinking and hearing theother character talking about it left me wondering to myself what I think about it. Talking about themes with other people is fun hearing their thoughts on these questions, the show just left me intrigued and thinking throughout it's entire run time, I do also think the answer to the final question was actually amazing and I didn't even think about that answer, nor people I talked to, usually when I watch mystery type series like this the answer or conclusion is usually not to my satisfaction or I don't care for it, but I generally love the answer they gave.
---Will have spoilers for the ending past this---
Now with the ending I was very confused and wondering, "WTF IS THIS", and I still do but there is only a few things that can happen to Zen after he killed the president on live Television. One: He goes to jail, Two: He dies (Either from Magase finally getting to him so he commits suicide or someone else shoots him), Three: This is not very realistic but the presidents agents who he was with during talking to the girl on TV helped Zen knowing some of the situation and he was able to go free under certain circumstances.
Obviously after the credits we see that nothing happened to Magase maybe Zen didn't shoot her because he didn't want to fall to evil and stick with his ideas of good, but either way she is still free in this world to end more people. I really like this ending cause usually it's the good guys winning but this time we have the villain win and in a very insane way. The ending leaves you in awe, with many questions, dumbfounded, and also disappointed if you didn't like the ending.
---End of spoilers---
Now overall I love this series, I think it has amazing themes, interesting and a wide range of characters, and for me an amazing ending I will be thinking about for awhile.
literaturenerd
Babylon is one of the oddest series of early 2020. That's impressive considering the fact it's competing against Ishuzoku Reviewers! Babylon is odd because it's tonally all over the place. An adult discussion about the ethics of suicide and euthanasia becomes a poorly written, Shonen cat and mouse game between Japanese Batman and an evil psychic who uses mind control powers to kill people. Did I mention her mind control powers work by being so incredibly sexy? Trust me, it's as dumb as it sounds. The story begins with Japanese prosecutor named Zen, investigating wrongdoing by a pharmaceutical giant. This leads to him discovering a murderand eventually this leads him to a shady politician named Itsuki. It turns out that Itsuki is bribing and killing politicians and other powerful figures in an elaborate scheme to create a new libertarian district of Tokyo. This will be a place where suicide is not only allowed, but often encouraged. To kick off the ceremony, he gets his psychic minion to kill 50 people by forcing them to jump off a building. The anime tries to write Itsuki as a well intentioned extremist. His motive is ultimately to donate his heart to his ailing son. Apparently, Japan currently has a law that suicide victims can't donate their organs. If that's his MO, why not just use his psychic minion to get a law through the Diet that says suicide victims CAN donate organs? Why create a new district, kill all these people, and go through all this shit? Well, it's so we can have a show!
Sadly, Itsuki doesn't get the bulk of the screen time. The main antagonist is the psychotic psychic, Ai Magase. Ai is basically the poor man's version of Legato Bluesummers from Trigun. She works the main villain and devotes her entire existence to make a pure, incorruptible soul suffer. She wishes to defeat Zen's idealism and force him to kill. Sadly, Ai never has Legato's intimidating presence. She's extremely over the top and her powers work in such a STUPID way. We have to believe that she's so sexy that it breaks people's minds. However, the show can't possibly draw her that sexy, so we're just left scratching our heads. Really? She's supposed to be THAT sexy? I'd give her a 6 being generous.
This is a series that wants to be adult and wants to be smart, but often it ends up just getting silly. When Zen chases Magase to America, we get to meet the greatest President ever! Alexander Wood was once the top ranked Diablo 2 player in the United States and an internet celebrity. After helping another player get good, she asked him out on a real life date and it turns out she was a super model! This gave Wood the confidence and popularity to become the President. We have a real estate mogul turned game show host as the President and that's still WAY more believable than this shit! Wood exists in the series to ask moral questions from a religious perspective. Wood is a devout Christian and doesn't know if suicide is wrong because the Bible doesn't explicitly forbid it. However, the writer of Babylon decided to make Wood a devout Catholic. The Catholic Church has clearly forbidden suicide for over 1,000 years! It makes little sense that Wood would struggle so much with this problem. Then again, this is the series where we're told Mark Twain was born in Connecticut and was a moral relativist who didn't believe in good or evil.
It seems like every time Babylon tries to be smart, it makes a blatantly wrong statement that the writer could have double checked on Wikipedia!
The art and animation by the brand new Studio Revoroot is quite good. It's a shame that Babylon's story doesn't hold up after the first 5-6 episodes. The music is done by the same guy that did the Vinland Saga OST. A lot of talent was involved in the making of Babylon. Unfortunately, I feel it mostly goes to waste.
If I could sum up Babylon with one word, it would be "disappointment". This looked like it would be a mature, intelligent anime that would ask difficult moral questions and challenge the way viewers see the world. Instead, it's a rather mediocre experience and far too messy for me to personally recommend.
CodeBlazeFate
*Prologue* Approaching this show is a difficult task. This isn’t because the show tackles harsh subject matter involving the likes of suicide as one of its fundamental talking points. It’s not because the show isn’t exactly good at doing so, either. It’s because I’m still coming to terms with what an absolute shitshow this series has become. There’s this immense swirl of emotions that come about from watching a show crumble before your very eyes, keenly aware that there were signs of trouble from the beginning. Babylon showed promise of being a fascinating police procedural with some of the most noteworthy directing of 2019...or at leastthat was the case for the first 7 episodes. Unfortunately, the last arc happened. Not only was I unable to accept any of the more idiotic decisions the show had been making as its presentation became blander and more obtuse, but the finale is one of the most devastating trainwrecks of recent years, invalidating almost everything the show had built up to that point.
*Part 1: The Rise*
Back when the show was about Zen Seizaki and his colleagues being wrapped up in a murder turned mass suicide mystery, the show had some of the best pacing of any recent seasonal. Its ability to generate tremendous cliffhangers was borderline unrivaled, even in the same year that Beastars and Promised Neverland came out. It never spent too much time dawdling on what the audience already knew or on presenting a character’s entire backstory since finding how the cause of a murder and eventually putting a stop to two people related to a string of suicides was at the forefront. Some of the characters that Zen interacted with, such as the morbidly nonchalant Shinobu Kujin and Zen’s first subordinate, Atsuhiko Fumino. Their banter often added a sense of levity to the tense first two arcs, and they’re involved in some of the more shocking scenes of the show.
The music was done by composer Yukata Yamada, the composer for the music of Vinland Saga. He creates several moody piano melodies that add to the show’s sense of gravitas. On top of that, there are some more electronic tracks that morph in ways that accentuate some of the show’s craziest moments and cliffhangers. The track “A Given” which plays during several key moments, is the perfect example of this. Unfortunately, as good as the soundtrack is, it often feels overplayed. Vinland Saga suffered a similar problem with its piano tracks, where the same few tracks are used in almost every episode. Regardless, there are several quality pieces here. The show’s 3 EDs are also fine songs in their own right, particularly 1 and 3. The first song “Live or Let Die” by Q-MHz feat. uloco, is a more chaotic piece while the last ED, adds a sense of finality to an arc that otherwise has none.
As for the visuals, this is Studio REVOROOT’s first full-length project and their second solo outing. The production values are rickety, with awkward CG environments and people scattered all over the place, and very few sequences that have much in the way of good animation. The show often feels jank, and the rough art style with white outlines does not help matters. Despite all of this, director Kiyotaka Suzuki was able to finally let loose after the horrible Psycho-Pass 2 and the decent yet already forgotten FLCL Alternative. The camera angles are often dynamic, there’s the usage of sepia tones and several interesting techniques. Episodes 2 and 7, in particular, have some of the most fascinatingly presented scenes of 2019. The former accentuates the sense of dread and confusion the former is meant to evoke, while the latter further conveys the sense of sheer agony that the main character feels in the final scene of episode 7. It’s a 5-minute torture sequence where the main character, Zen Siezeki, is forced to watch someone get cut to pieces as his ideology crumbles to the helplessly crumbles to the ground after everything he has been through. This is where the show peaks and you should stop, before the direction largely begins falling flat, and the show takes a tremendous nosedive.
*Part 2: The Fall*
**spoilers beyond this point**
Where do I begin? Just know that I'm not even gonna go over everything that was particularly off about the show's writing.
The first sign of trouble came at the end of the first arc, when it turned out that the new mayor of Shiniki had proposed a suicide law, making it do that you can commit die of your own free will without penalty since apparently that's actually illegal. He insisted this by having dozens of people gleefully jump off a building. Needless to say, this required a bit of suspension of disbelief.
It turns out that this was made possible by Ai Magase whispering in their ears. There are several, several problems with Ai and her powers in general.
A. She has offscreen shapeshifting powers. This isn't like with Fujiko Mine and other femme fatales that put on disguises. With those, they generally wear feasible wigs and can be identified by their face if you know what they normally look like. With Ai, despite having long hair, she can easily pull off all hair sizes, and her face can become unrecognizable with how different it is. It's as if between disguises which sometimes get deployed within mere minutes of one another, Ai goes through plastic surgery. It goes beyond having convincing disguises and into the realm of having supernatural abilities.
B. Mere moments before ending his own life, Shinobu tells our main protagonist that Ai can convince someone to uncontrollably want to kill themselves. Even the most steadfast and iron-willed individuals have a hard time resisting, so whatever she says, you do. It's how she was able to get out of interrogation in episode 2, and how all of those people in episode 3 ended up jumping off. As of the finale, it turns out that her saying...anything is grounds for suicide, rather than her seductively whispering a suggestion for you to kill yourself.
What's wrong with this picture? In this seemingly grounded police procedural with no confirmed supernatural elements, it seems a bit asinine for her to be able to pull this off with just her voice. What's stupider is that she doesn't even need to even specify that you have to die. In the finale, she whispers the phrase "good job" into the earpiece President Alexander Wood had on with his translators after speaking to a Japanese girl who was considering taking her own life. This was enough to get him to attempt suicide. Ridiculous, isn't it? Even more ridiculous than the idea that her whispering can trigger suicidal urges while her talking does nothing. Sure, whispering can be more seductive, but this is absurd. On top of that, there's a contradiction in the previous sentence. How come the horde of building jumpers in episode 3 kept themselves together and jumped off only on someone else's cue rather than their own accord while everyone else was unable to control their urges? This isn't the biggest issue, but it is still another knock against her whisper powers from a writing perspective
C. Episode 5. In middle school, she was somehow able to walk and talk in such a way that every male she encountered found themselves feeling so unbearably lustful that they genuinely felt raped. Even in the 7 episode grace period, I had a hard time swallowing this pill. Walking seductively is admittedly a thing but this is just tasteless and asinine. Luckily the idea of rape never comes up again, but this was definitely where I started to realize that maybe Babylon might be full of shit sometimes.
D. Ai herself is a rather disappointing character. She’s flash without the fire. She’ll get inside Zen’s head with borderline inane monologues about good and evil, but thanks to the director going ham during those sequences, they’re some of the most entertaining in the show. They obfuscate how dumb and insubstantial her dialogue is, like when in episode 7, she is trying to make Zen think about what evil really is (despite him doing so but I guess his answers don’t align with hers, which we’ll get to) all hile butchering one of his subordinates right in front of him. All she amounts to is just a person who loves being evil and wants to spread an asinine notion of good and evil around. One of her interactions with Zen reveals that in spite of and because of the villainous acts she is knowingly doing, she believes she’s some hero spreading an important message, doing a service to humanity so they’ll understand what good and evil really are. It would have been interesting if part of Ai’s motivation was for people to be able to understand her, and what it must have felt like to feel almost alien to everyone around her as everyone always thinks of her as a twisted, enigmatic female figure. That sure went nowhere despite the show delving into how she received therapies that ended up being worthless to her and how she finds this plight to get people to understand her version of good and evil to be a just cause.
The other major antagonist, Itsuki, isn’t that great either. While he does get an interesting debate in episodes 6 and 7 where he reveals that he wants to die so his kid can have his heart during a necessary heart transplant surgery that may happen in the future, afterwards he has almost no presence in the show. Nothing regarding his suicide law even gets resolved by the end. Speaking of characters that get shafted in the final arc, the last 5 episodes had the potential to really show how bad Zen’s mental state is after every single one of his colleagues in his field got killed. While episode 8 has him hallucinating here and there, that’s the last time the show does anything particularly captivating. Afterwards, he states his desire vengeance, gets aggy at a recording of her voice, and then fades into the background until the finale. Everyone else who survived the first two arcs gets thrown to the wayside as well, including Zen’s family that have death flags all around them despite nothing happening to them.
Before we get...there, one character relevant to the finale has to be mentioned, as no one else is that interesting or important enough to bring up. Alexander Wood gets introduced via a scene where he monologues his life story to the audience, about how he got a girlfriend, how he became god tier at this MMORPG, how he now has a wealthy family and a kid that’s healthier than he could ever be, and everything. Not only is that a terrible way to introduce a character, but it becomes the first sign that the wonderful pacing of the show would go downhill. Then you learn he’s also the president. I’ll let that one sit on the part of your brain that’s forced to process it. He thinks a lot and is a decent guy. That’s really all there is to him.
*Part 3: THE ENDING*
You ever think of a worst case scenario for how a promising show you're not entirely sure about will play out, and then wish you got that instead of whatever the fuck you just saw? That's Babylon's finale. It might be one of the worst endings I have ever seen.
Throughout the entirety of the show, there have been two main ideological conflicts at play: the nature of good and evil, and the ethics/logistics of suicide/the suicide law. Episodes 6 had an engaging debate where several government heads oppose the suicide law through the socio-economic, moral/ethical, the extreme scenario and accusations, and and “people naturally avoid death” perspectives. While they may have felt surface level due to them getting one minute to make one point, it was at least able to offer up several perspectives that would logically be used to approach controversial laws.
Episode 11 has world leaders make strawman viewpoints about how “people gain their sense of morality through us leaders so we much teach them that suicide is wrong” while completely forgetting that most people still consider suicide wrong and that no one gets their sense of morality through world, country, or state leaders. The other viewpoints expressed are no better and just result in mindless bickering before President Wood decides that we need to examine the nature of good and evil in order to determine a unanimous position on the suicide law. What follows is the most tiresome deliberation I have ever heard, as everyone just spins their wheels examining the two most common and basic moral quandaries without actually pressing the issue further than the most surface-level ideas barely getting much exploration. My logistics class went further into moral dilemmas and that is a class where we learn about jobs, warehouse jobs, and forklift-driving. This is the epitome of the show’s incessant wheel-spinning on its topics, as even before this point it has already become a cyclical game of “what is good, what is bad, what is justice?” getting shallow, simplistic exploration despite the show constantly acknowledging how complex these issues are.
That whole idea means nothing anyway and is an excuse to wax about concepts the show barely has a grasp on before Pres Alex Wood is called to convince a girl not to jump off a building. Itsuki, who initiated the summit, sets this up. In the last episode, Alex gets a translator and gets to work. The day is saved until it turns out that after this, all of the translators (since apparently there is more than one despite there being only one volunteer) are dead and Ai Magase, who is disguised as someone that was not in the building and was never shown prior, whispers “good job” in good ol Woody’s ear. After this, we never hear about Itsuki or the suicide law ever again. During the convo, SudoWOODo finally comes up with the answers to what good and bad are.
Good = continue
Bad = end
Let’s talk about how mind-shatteringly stupid this is. If continuing is inherently a good thing, does it remain that way when applied to the act of continuing to murder innocent people? What about continuing to bully people? What about continuing to swindle people, kill animals for the hell of it, gamble all your money away, suffer, etc? Can continuing be used in a positive context in those situations? No. Is continue just the show’s silly and obnoxious way of saying life? No, but that’s the only context being applied to the term in the show. You can apply it positively to say, continuing to prosper, continuing to help people, etc. but the show isn’t smart enough to do so. The idea of ending being a bad thing is just as stupid. Should “end world hunger, end your addiction, end someone’s torture, end the show on a high note, end your career with one great game, etc.” be used negatively? No. Is “end” the show’s shorthand for “end your life”? Probably. Can you apply end in a negative light with ideas such as “end someone’s life, end someone’s career, end your relationship (that one can be positive or negative), etc.”? Yes, but the show doesn’t think of that because it’s too busy thinking it has all the answers to a broad concept.
This, ladies and gentlemen, is what Ai Magasee, that fucking idiot, wanted to spread to the world. This is what Zen ends up answering with once he and the president figure it out after a standoff where Zen has to shoot Wood in order to prevent him from committing suicide. As laughable as that sequence is, the idea that he has to stop Wood from killing himself after the man had just talked a girl out of ending her own life on international television, is the smartest thing the finale could come up with. After this, it is implied that through this last standoff, despite Zen pointing a gun at Ai and her just pointing a finger gun gesture at him, he dies and she gets to walk off and meet his kids. That is how the show ends, with the most anticlimactic and nonsensical ambiguous ending I have ever seen.
Also, in episode 11, Morning Wood decides that perhaps the key to answering the suicide law debate and the fundamental nature of good and evil is to decipher the meaning of life. This never gets brought up again. The suicide law gets no resolution as we never find out what the decision was regarding the law or anything about what would happen to it either. Itsuki and his new country, Shiniki, just disappear halfway into the finale. Ai does not even get challenged by Zen despite him pointing a gun at her after everything she had done to him and to hundreds of people. The three main conceits of the show, all rendered moot in the span of 10 minutes. None of this meant a damn thing, and all it would amount to is negative answers and Zen potentially being dead without feeling like his rivalry with Magase ever really came to a head. The entire show was just one big waste of time. You could honestly just stop at the first scene of episode 8 and act like Ai drove Zen irreparably insane while she wreaks havoc on the world. It’s about as conclusive as what we actually got, and a lot less stupid to boot.
There is one last thing to mention before we wrap things up. There’s an easy fix to the suicide law debacle, one that is based on what Itsuki wished would happen. The answer is simply to treat it on a case by case basis, making sure to educate people on the ramifications their actions would have on their families and those around them before they decide to off themselves. The more knowledgeable they are of the severe effects taking your own life would have, the less likely they are of committing suicide and the more open and knowledgeable they would be regarding the subject. Not once is this idea brought up in the final arc of the show by any of the world leaders, when at least one politician in the second arc weaponizes this idea.
*Epilogue*
To all the people hesitant about this show and its writer after the hellfire that was Kado’s finale: you were right to steer clear. Truly this is a case where the ending will overshadow the show as a whole after eliminating any goodwill many had with the show’s first 7 episodes. Honestly, the cover is the most clever and thought-provoking aspect of this pretentious mess, and the “p-word” is a condemnation I don’t use lightly. Spare yourself the disappointment, aggravation, and sense of betrayal. There are a lot of silly moments and twists I did not even go over, and as I was writing this review, it became genuinely difficult to remember the more positive aspects of the show’s writing. The more I think about it, the worse the show gets. For something meant to be more intellectual, filled with more gravitas than your average anime, this is perhaps the most succinctly damning thing I can say about it. Let this be a lesson that if an anime looks like it can go either way, it's probably going south.
sushiisawesome
Babylon is yet the latest in a series of blunders courtesy of the seinen demographic that in many ways sum up exactly why the majority of people shun it in favor of its younger brother in the shonen demographic. It's not that I personally think seinen can't be fantastic; plenty of series have done a marvelous job living up to what the demographic, well, implies and providing interesting characters, a level of maturity not normally found in their younger contemporaries and fantastic storylines. After all, one only needs to look at the likes of Berserk, Vinland Saga, Boogiepop and Others as well as Ghost inthe Shell to know that there are many fantastic titles to find.
What Babylon is, however, is a travesty of the highest order, thoroughly incapable of telling any sort of coherent narrative and being thoroughly unsatisfying to watch. On paper, a story covering euthanasia, nihilism and morality sounds like a fantastic narrative that should intrigue even the most uninterested viewers. In practice, however, what is found here is complete and utter drivel.
Babylon is essentially a story about a man who's lost several acquaintances to suicide, but the suicide were in some shape or form them being convinced by a lady that life is meaningless and they should off themselves. It'd take an exceptional amount of careful writing to make this work, but thankfully, Babylon proceeds to butcher it through how exactly it treats the subjects it's discussing like a complete joke.
Scenes where characters literally jump off rooftops in complete synchronicity. Debates about why people should commit suicide in public. Strawmen being committed ad nauseum about how religions don't condone suicide and how if you're not religious there's no point to life. Entire discussions by various politicians about how euthanasia works which ironically ignore the little misstep where in several countries where it's legalized if you're healthy should visit several mental health clinics and provide evidence of that, and it's not as simple as just going there and killing yourself.
This kind of bad writing plagues the entire show from start to finish, and it's clear that the writer has no idea how police works, no idea how the euthanasia debate works and an extremely shallow understanding of contemporary nihilism. And the worst part is, it makes entire segments of the show where characters proceed to end their lives - which you'd expect to be a gutwrenching or painful moment to watch - instead be a complete joke and unintentionally comedic instead.
The dialogue is also noteworthy in how dry, bland and soulless it is. There's no personality to the dialogue, merely poorly researched strawman fallacies everywhere when there are discussions, and the characters' personalities never shine through the dialogue either. You could swap characters and have them speak entirely different conversations under this script and yet I promise you wouldn't notice a thing, because the series isn't interested in making its cast shine or the dialogue matter except to infodump about the poorly written setting.
The plot is a complete and utter laughable mess as a result of all this, and making things even worse is how uneven the pacing is. And while uneven pacing isn't necessarily something that'd doom the show, there's nothing worse than a show that feels like it's going too fast and too slowly at the same time, and this becomes especially noteworthy when the soulless excuse for a cast get involved.
I genuinely have nothing to say about the cast, they can literally be defined in one liners and minus the main villain, none of them had any strength of screen presence or personality worth remembering. They don't drive the plot forward, they exist in service of it; countless times are characters introduced, speak a few lines and then killed either later in the episode or the next episode, as if the audience's sympathy will be won over by just watching some random mook get slaughtered. And the worst thing is that this caused a massive disconnect between me, who didn't care about these dull, soulless one note characters, and the main character who clearly did.
A particular mention needs to go for the main villain of this show for being hilariously ridiculous every time she showed up on screen, asking about whether the main character had sex or what his kinks were and always constantly messing with all the characters on screen. She was the sole character that stood out in a sea of dull, boring, empty robots and I'm genuinely glad she was there. Special mention goes for her actions in the last episode and the epilogue to the show, which actually made me lose it laughing my head off.
On a technical level, the show is competent; while not much animation or movement exists in the show, special mention needs to go to the direction of the show, which consistently looked good and made a fair few otherwise dull scenes more tolerable. That being said, the direction also made the show hilariously bad at times due to how completely over the top the portrayal of the main villain was, which I'll admit I appreciate and made me look forward to at least seeing her on screen.
I never thought the sound design was particularly bad, and while nothing was memorable from the soundtrack I never thought anything was unfitting. It's clear there were some talented staff members behind this project and it's a real shame that this is what they were relegated to work on.
The core problem with this show is that by the time I finished, I had no idea what the point of the show was. Many people would proudly mention that this show was this sophisticated commentary on euthanasia and suicide, but truthfully I never felt it was competent in what it was tackling, only that it was mildly entertaining when it starts and slowly but surely fizzled out, like a pretentious old man whose advice no one is interested in hearing because everyone knows it's false. And this, ultimately, makes this show just a complete waste of everyone's time.
At best, the show is unintentionally comedic with bland, soulless characters who I never cared for. At worst, this show is a painful slog that I only finished because it was airing and for no other reason other than to see what some people were overhyping all over the internet. And like many a forgotten, boring seinen, it too will be remembered only for having all the same flaws that most other entries in the demographic do, and for similarly having its fanbase in the first few episodes exhibit everything wrong with the kind of people who rally behind these kinds of shows.
Your time is better spent watching something else, be it watching a properly done crime thriller, reading some book about euthanasia or nihilism, or doing anything else you find enjoyable. It certainly isn't well spent on this show, and I recommend that if you haven't seen it, to not waste your time doing so.
And yes, while I can make this review longer and flesh out my points more, I don't consider this show worth putting in that much effort, because if the writers didn't care about putting any level of effort into what they've done here, why should I?
anime-prime
Babylon is like a plane crash. It takes off well, flies in the air for a nice while, but in the end it just couldn't stick the landing and it just flopped down in an explosion. What could go wrong for a show with such potential, lets find out. Story: Babylon is about a detective who is trying to catch a woman who can kill with her voice. That is it. Imagine Death Note flipped where the main focus is on L who is trying to catch Kira but we never get Kiras perspective. He is just a character who stays in the background. That isexactly this show. And that might have been its downfall.
The rest:
Everything besides the storytelling is very good. The sound, art, and characters are all well done. If it was written better this could have been a great anime.
Enjoyment:
I enjoyed this show until episode 7 where it takes a narrative shift so immense that it wouldn't surprise me if it have been written by a different person. Then it becomes boring and dumb.
Overall:
I can't forget that 1/2 of it was really good, but that last 1/2 has me switching from a great show to an okay show. What happened to make it change so drastically?
The Problems:
1: Like I said before, this is a flipped Death Note. Change the perspective to only the main character Zen Seizaki (L) and don't focus on the villain Ai Magase (Kira). Ai can instead of using a death note can use her seductive voice to control people to kill themselves. Cool, right? However it is never explained. It is hinted that there might be drugs that she is using on her victims but that is completely forgotten about and instead suggested that she is like the snake of the garden of Eden (pure seductive evil). In a realistic show you can't just make up reasons for powers. Use the drug angle, or introduce her as the devil from the beginning of the show. Make her a main narrative character to give us some insight. But no, instead make it seem that she just has the power to turn on every possible gender so much that they get so aroused that they just need to kill themselves. That seems legit!? And why would she do it? Because she was born like that? That is terrible writing. They had her go to a shrink, they showed a little back story. That could have been used to see how she turned out like that from a psychological standpoint, but instead, she is the devil and she can apparently shape shift into whoever she wants. That is just lazy writing. Unlike Death Note where you might root for both characters, here there is no perspective from the antagonists, thus there is no reason to be invested in Ai besides for the mystery to be solved and her caught. But since neither happen, she wasn't used to her full potential.
2: The narrative shifts from catching her to a political debate over if you can kill yourself. The show depicts this in such an unrealistic and dumb way that it is hard to put it to words. The concept and execution of the debate are just badly handled.
I don't like talking about politics because no matter what you say you will cause a fight but I believe most people can agree that this show didn't do a good job depicting the debates between what is good and evil.
3: The ending has no satisfying resolution. After the president and Zen confront each other in the last scene before the end credit scene with Ai enjoying the show from the sidelines, it is like they knew they messed up so they just quit trying. I am sure that the White House had plenty of time to find a way to save the president from the possible jump, but besides that, Zen could have shot his leg or arm to stop him from jumping but shoots his chest instead?! Why?! And how would the president not only not fall backwards, but fall forwards instead? If he only injured the president who only afterwards fell because of the shot then the result of suicide wouldn't have been considered because it was murder, and if he didn't fall, then he would have saved his life. There was absolutely no reason to go for the kill shot and he had everything to gain to go for a minor injury. After that, he could of killed Ai right away but he hesitates for no reason. The end is left up to interpretation but the way I see it, Mai not only gets off scott free (because escaping from the White House is as easy as sneaking into it apparently) but there is never any resolution for her character. She just continues her life. The president also didn't get any resolution because he was stopped by Ai before he could benefit from it. The only resolution is for Zen but it was poor because if he did kill himself at the end then not only did he not catch Ai, but he also failed in the narrative because the show was going for the angle of letting go of anger but it also goes nowhere.
4: In the end, I didn't see a point in what the show was trying to say. First a mystery thriller which isn't even told in good detective fashion, then a political mess of suicide talks all without a solid piece of perspective from the angle of the antagonists. What were the creators trying to say with this anime? Don't do suicide? You don't need to make an anime about it, but if you do, direct it better than this show.
Score: 8 (good and had some great elements but I wouldn't rewatch it).
DarthInvader
*Minimum Spoiler Review* TL;DR: Psycho Pass meets Mirai Nikki before they have a child so horrible they decide to leave it at the philosophy class for freshman's to decide what religion the child will have. [Story: 6/10 , Characters: 5/10, Art: 5/10, Sound: 4/10, Enjoyment: 3/10] “a woman sitting on a scarlet beast that was full of blasphemous names, and it had seven heads and ten horns. The woman was arrayed in purple and scarlet, and adorned with gold and jewels and pearls, holding in her hand a golden cup full of abominations and the impurities of her sexual immorality. And on her forehead was writtena name of mystery: “Babylon the great, mother of prostitutes and of earth’s abominations.” And I saw the woman, drunk with the blood of the saints, the blood of the martyrs of Jesus.” (Revelation 17:3–6 ESV)
Thriller anime's make it or break it point is how well it can balance the dynamic between the protagonist, the antagonist and the philosophical dilemma they both deal with to justify the decision they have made by the end. From the director that brought us, FLCL Alternative & Psycho Pass 2 (not one) comes a new thriller called Babylon where our major philosophical debate is whether people should be allowed to commit suicide, thus making it an universal law. The topic of suicide, assisted suicide, and the whole idea of the justice surrounding it is any philosophy 101's students' wet dream. We think we know what is good and what is evil but as we slowly group and become poisoned by society's corruption we learn in order to continue living we must tread on a moral grey line. Although this show had a fine premise and a mystery element surrounding this core theme of suicide with a good protagonist and a very vibrant antagonist, by the end it expanded too much to quickly for it to become the next great Psycho Pass of a show. Fortunately, it did generate ton of controversy, and where there is controversy, there is popularity. So let's discuss why this dark horse of a show had the potential but just like Icarus, it flew too close to the sun of philosophy and burned down to the ashes. Let the fun begin.
With a clever title like Babylon, you immediately start thinking of two things, the great kingdom of Babylon or the whore of Babylon (if you know about the Biblical story). For those who don't know, the Whore of Babylon is the spirit of seductive culture, actively engaged in the deception and destruction of God’s people. Now without getting into the religious fundamentals, the story's central theme is basically justifying what is good and what is evil. Should people be allowed to commit suicide or is it a crime to in general. How do we judge what is good and how do we judge what is evil. Various philosophical issues come to play and this theme is portrayed through the conflict between Zen Seizaki (Prosecutor aka Batman) and Ai Magase (Whore of Babylon aka Joker). If you understand the reference of Batman & Joker dynamic akin to the Dark Knight movie, you'll understand better of how the plot is played out without spoiling too much. Essentially the issue arises in a small town of Shiniki, where this young Mayoral candidate Itsuki, proposes that suicide becomes legal. He explains his reasonings and he has Ai Magase carry out the "suicides" of the people in the city. For the first arc the show becomes this cat and mouse game of capturing Ai Magase and finding more about her before she "kills off" Zen's team via the method of suicide. It's brutal, thrilling and a nail biter to see who can out wit the other. They even introduced a drug early on, Nyux drug, that people can take to die in peace instead of the usual jumping off or cutting oneself or hanging method. In a nutshell, they were humanizing the process to be more ethical to today's standards. Sadly, in the second arc of the story, the suicide law went from a city policy to a universal policy, expanding to countries like Canada, France, Germany, Italy, UK to even USA. We get to see now political leaders of the country getting in on the debate. Oddly this also coincides with when the show went on a long hiatus before returning and it seemed people smoked too much because the whole tone of the show changed. It became too philosophical for its own good and less chaotic battle of wits where the characters were playing 4D chess to outwit one another. It definitely lost its charm and the show ended on an open ending for viewers to decide and talk about to learn more.
With a philosophical show as such, it's not actions or "plot" that attracts the audience, it’s the characters that offer the charm, particularly the villain. In Ai Magase, we see a diluted villain akin to Shogo Makashima of the past. She has this mystical aura with the whole Whore of Babylon biblical allusion as well as the Nine Tails folklore in Japan. She has the power to verbally mindfuck someone to submission to the point of them wanting to commit suicide without actually physically murdering them. On the other hand we have Zen Seizaki, this super moral good guy to the level of Superman and as the show progress we see how he slowly loses his sanity to maintain his core fundamentals so he doesn't become the very evil person he puts behind in jail. This Batman vs Joker dynamic is the central conflict in this entire show. Now to foil these characters and flesh out the good vs evil character grid, we have side characters like Detective Kujin, Prosecutor Sekuro, Mayor Itsuki, even the president of the US all the Americans hope to have, Alexander Wood, and many more. As the show progress, we see these characters give their output on where they stand on the issue and what we need to do as society. Once again, very open ended and lacking the mangaka's clear feeling towards this situation.
Looking at the technical aspects, this is one of those shows that doesn't need Studio Ufotable level animation, nor does it Studio Bones level music to make the show pop. It's a thought provoking anime and key people were the seiyuus voicing the characters. The seiyuu of Ai Magase and Zen Seizaki does a phenomenal job conveying the raw emotions and the quirks they have plus more. The OST is alright, nothing too crazy and animation is passable. A few freeze panes here and there but they cleaned it up near the end. Not too shabby overall. The OP and ED songs or rather medleys are alright. Nothing too great. Nothing too memorable.
Nevertheless, Babylon is an okay anime at the end of the day. It definitely had a great premise as a mystery thriller where we had to catch the "Whore of Babylon" before she corrupted God's people and led them to their deaths but it deviated in the second arc to this philosophy 101 bullshit about what is good, what is evil, what is justice and what it means to commit suicide. Not once did they just grow a pair and address the major issue of there is a cult leader, let's arrest the cult leader before they convert more to commit a mass murder. Nope, they were too good to do such a thing and as a result only our naïve boy, Seizaki suffers. It sort of mirrors the political climate of Japan in today's society where due to their naivety is currently suffering and in a population decline due to their ignorance of core issues early on when the problems were surfacing. So I guess kudos to the mangaka to mirror that. If the anime was stretched to a two cour anime, maybe it would've been far better since people would actually have a proper debate and not one or two lines to debate a serious matter as such. Regardless, viewers who like anime like Psycho Pass or Monster or Parasyte, should give this anime a watch. It's not going to be as good as those anime but atleast it will tickle your philosophical bone for a few hours. I'd never rewatch this anime and I hope there is an OVA to wrap up the loose ends. Anyways, thank you for reading this review & feel free to share with me your favourite quote from the anime. Ciao.
P.S. Thank you for reading. I hope you found this short and supaishi review helpful!
P.P.S. If you got through it all, do answer me this on my profile the following questions:
1) What makes suicide a crime but euthanasia not a crime?
2) Will letting suicide being a universal law solve the issue for organ donation?
3) If suicide becomes an universal law, how can one punish someone to prevent from population committing mass suicide?
OugiRevolution
SPOILER FREE REVIEW Story: Psychological thriller anime are so few and far between, that if you like the genre it is possible you have seen most of them to date. Babylon provides a twisted, dark, yet philosophical story that easily sucks its watcher in deeper with each passing episode. I can't recall ever seeing an anime quite like this one. The pacing for episodes 1-7 is flawless, but 8-12 can feel slow at times if you are only in it for suspense. Personally, I didn't mind the slower episodes since I found the topics of discussion interesting. The storyline's clarity (especially the ending)was what I struggled most with, since at points it's was very vague. Of course, I think it's highly possible that the level of uncertainty was intended by the writers, but it can leave viewers disappointed. Still, there is a lot of merit in the way they left the ending, especially if you enjoy shows without a concrete wrap-up (like 91 Days).
Story: 9/10
Art:. The animation for Babylon was absolutely incredible, and it always created the desired atmosphere. It reminded me of Alfred Hitchcock movies like Rear Window or Vertigo. Darkness with oozing from every scene in the first half of the show, and when things took a change around episode 10, so did the art. It lightened up a bit, which was a bit of a bummer, but it still looked gorgeous. The character designs were awfully pretty too. Especially that of the MC and the main antagonist.
Art: 9/10
The voice acting was superb and background music was really atmospheric. There isn't much else to say, since I have nothing but praise for both of these areas. Other sounds like rain, cars, guns - all were exceptional as well.
Sound: 9/10
Characters are the make it/break it feature of many shows, and Babylon is no exception. The way these characters acted was probably the best I've seen in any psychological thriller anime. The MC shows that each dark thing that happens is having an effect on him; while the main antagonist could perhaps be my top anime villain of 2019. Only a few of the side characters felt a bit weak (the US President and the MCs Assistant), but the main ones more than make up for that.
Characters: 9/10
My enjoyment for Babylon is considerably higher than other psychological thriller like Erased, since it also brings into question important philosophical problems that still plague the mind of ethicists today. As someone who studies Ethics/Philosophy in University, I think the topics were discussed well; however, I know they aren't for everyone. There is plenty of suspense (at least in the first half) for people just seeking thrills, but if you are looking for a brooding, dark rollercoaster that makes you question good/evil, look no further than Babylon.
Enjoyment/Overall: 9/10
ShouKyng
The suicidal theme is not addressed in many anime, and sometimes it is not addressed properly. But this anime approaches this theme very well. In "Babylon" , the time location is in what I can say is a contemporan Japan ( so the contemporan world ) which is perfect for this theme. As for the location itself it's a made up one, so by herself it can't really give us more context about the actions ( Shiniki - that means the new city ) The suicidal theme is approached in a legal way which makes it really interesting as suicide isnot legal ot illegal . In the anime , what can I say is the secondary antagonist, tries to make suicide legal by any means ( mostly legal means ) and he succeeds.
The interesting part here is not necessarily the characters, the action , etc ... What is important here ar the ideas and the arguments. The ideas and the arguments that are used in making the suicide act legal. These are so important from the perspective that with them suicide had legalised ( ofcourse those ideas/arguments are taken to an extreme and sometimes utopic thinking). (a thing that really scared me , was that this could actually be possible in real life )
Besides this look at the anime by only it's , let's say dialogue, it's not the full "look". "Babylon" has to offer thrilling action scenes ( here , viewer discretion is advised as many scenes can be found disturbing ) , a mostly original protagonist design ( a prosecutor ) ,a very interesting main antagonist ( a woman with a ability that's borderline fantastic, the ability to make anyone suicide with just a few words ) and side/episodic caracthers that actually matter and don't have just some bland personalities.
Overall , I recommend this anime for watching, with the short notice that it isn't for everyone.
UnluckyCat13
I want to address three points with this review. If you should watch the show; defending the show; criticizing the show. Should you watch the show? Pretty simple: Yes. This is the best psychological anime I've seen since Psychopass. I think it's even good outside of the realm of just comparing it to anime, but it certainly does things in a way that only anime can. But, the show is graphic. It deals with a lot about suicide. If suicide upsets you in any way, do not watch the show. Otherwise, please go in blind. The rest of this review will contain minor spoilers, butnot in a describing the things that happened kind of way, however it's worth noting that even the premise of the show could be perceived as a spoiler to some degree. Unlike some other anime , it's not a genre bait and switch but an unraveling mystery that causes the spoilers.
I'll start by addressing the current top review on this site. No, this show is not pro-suicide. I can see why someone would think that way, but the entire conflict is between characters who are attempting to stop the mainstreaming of suicide and antagonists who have nefarious plans. The very end of the show itself is the rejection of suicide as an option.
There are some criticisms people have about the show ignoring the mental health component, and I think that's fair. I would counter that the mental health component may be overstated by some people, and that it is somewhat addressed. You have to remember that this is a Japanese show, and it addressed concerns in Japan and with a Japanese understanding. In Asia (and in the rest of the world too) the reason people commit suicide is not always mental health. Monks in Tibet light themselves on fire and burn to death to protest China. In 'ancient' Japan, Samurai would kill themselves and engage in duels to the death purely for honor. In Japan there is the infamous "Suicide Forest". One aspect of how it got its name, is that the elderly people who were unable to care for themselves care for themselves and believed themselves to be a burden to their families would go there to die.
Some would cite that last example as depression. I can agree that depression may play into a decision like that, however this is a topic that has been examined in western media as well. In Star Trek: TNG there is an episode called Half Life. It deals with a planet in which the culture of the society is that those over a certain age will kill themselves in a public ceremony, which is considered good and even virtuous. In the film Midsommar there is a cult where the elderly kill themselves, and this cult is not necessarily framed as entirely evil. I don't like Star Trek or Midsommar and how you feel about them isn't that important either. I'm just saying that the concept of killing yourself due to being incapable of contributing to society and to stop old age is not some radical, new, Japanese fringe idea. Many people have experiences in which they state they would rather die than continue on with life, such as dementia.
The anime does also bring up a number of other points in which someone might, without the aid of mental illness, kill themselves. One example I felt was pretty compelling was father donating his organs to his dying son. Is that really even his son? Is his son dying? You could argue we don't actually know but it's something of a mute point. The actual argument itself is very adequate regardless of the showmanship around it.
Mental Health is brought up when they reference "running away". That is the mental health take on suicide, and I do believe that is the common societal view on it in the west as well. However, I don't think that suicide is ALWAYS a matter of running away. That is almost the definition of a controversial take, but we can look to countries in which assisted suicide is being discussed or implemented. There are conditions in which some do consider ending your suffering to be a reasonable conclusion to some issues.
I also believe there is some element of satire to some of the anti suicide arguments that were brought up. Discussing the GDP of your nation and the effect of suicide on the economy may technically be a valid argument, however it's obviously as abhorrent to some people as the idea of being pro-suicide.
In general the conversation skewed towards a very Japanese view on things. For example, giving your life for war isn't brought up because modern, current day Japan says war is bad. I think that you have to center your criticism a little bit when you're remembering this is a Japanese work aimed at Japanese people from a Japanese point of view. It doesn't mean you can't leverage criticism at it, but you should keep in mind why something is occurring in the first place.
There's a more general criticism by people that the entire premise of the anime is stupid because you can't criminalize killing yourself. Well I'm sorry to tell you, you're wrong if you believe that. In some countries suicide is literally illegal, and you can be punished if you live. Even putting that aside, some would say that locking people up and controlling their right to bodily autonomy is akin to a punishment as well, we just call it treatment or rehabilitation. And if you do believe that suicide is someone's right, then it is in fact a punishment. We also often call prisons and parole "rehabilitation". So for all intents and purpose to someone who wants to commit suicide, it is illegal. That's before you even get into the case of assisted suicide. The Suicide Law in the anime is about more than just rather or not it's illegal however.
It's about government support. Itsuki says it several times and he is very clear about it. He wants the government to create pills which facilitate a painless, clean suicide. He wants there to be facilities which assist people with their choice to end their lives. He wants a social acceptance of suicide, which will promote the ability for people to publicly discuss rather it's the right choice for them without fear of reprisal. Itsuki would like the entire institution and our thoughts on suicide to be changed.
Once again, we've entered a Japanese perspective that some westerners are not familiar with. In America at least, we have a very individualistic view towards things. We don't like to think about how the state, or law, or elders influence us. However, we do often look to the law as a sign of morality. Many people consider morality and obeying the law to either be the same thing or morally linked. People say things like "I'm not breaking any laws am I?" Beyond that, people look to others for their cue on what is socially acceptable and how to behave. Japan is a society that values how you contribute to it and gel with it possibly more than how you feel as an individual. From a Japanese perspective, doing right by your family and society is more important than your individual thoughts. This is reflected in many anime in which the main character breaks free of those shackles and does whatever he wants. This is reflected in this anime by characters doing the exact opposite of the typical shounen protagonist.
Sekuro is just one embodiment of this. She is like the main character. she does not want to be involved in an unlawful conspiracy that goes against her INDIVIDUAL sense of justice. In spite of this, she is pressured by society and her family relations to work for the main character. She does not want to do this but she must. It is both literally and metaphorically her job. The anime is full of people playing their roles, and doing what they believe is right by society in an attempt to find what is right for them. It is most thoroughly reflected in the young girl who commits suicide on the train tracks though. (To address another criticism, this is an actual kind of bridge that exists, not just crazy anime design).
Gay rights are brought up a lot in this anime as an example and a counter example. I do not think this is a dig at LGBT people. If you listen to the arguments made for and against suicide in the anime, several of them are arguments previously applied to gay rights. IN AMERICA no less. "If you legalize or decriminalize homosexuality, then everyone will be free to do it and people will think it's okay." Crazy! "You might even encourage children to do it on accident," "Children will be confused," "If children see their idols doing it they will want to imitate it," "It's not our place to decide what people do with their bodies," "Times change".
I realize a lot of modern anime viewers are not very old, so some things in this anime don't really hit home with them. I'm 30, I lived through these conversations. In my lifetime you could literally be prosecuted, or treated to electroshock therapy for being gay or transgender. In my life time, I have seen politicians do things similar to what they have done in this anime, to address another criticism of the series. Characters behaving in a way that isn't the way you would behave, or a way that you don't think is realistic, is not unrealistic or a plot hole. It is a thing that happens in real life. What's important in my opinion is that the characters actions are internally congruent and not completely out of place, so let me address some plot specific points (which will contain minor spoilers).
There was no security camera in that interrogation room. That is why they had to write everything down, that is why they could not check the security footage to see what Ai did. The reason the main character tolerates the antagonist sending threatening stuff to his house is because he literally has to. At that point not only is he a broken man, he has no authority to go after her. The police and government are covering everything up, and she's on the side of the ruling power in the city which even the nation of Japan does not want to go against. This is not a battle shounen, the main character cannot rise up and fight the authority, or overthrow it. Anime of this genre often deal with the system being too powerful to fight against or escape (Ghost in the Shell, Psychopass).
There are several points in the show I don't care for. While the show is not sexist, it does partake in somewhat sexist writing. The female characters are generally wives or exist to be murdered or flaunting their sexuality. the show does not do any favors to pretty much any female character in it, which is really just frustrating to see. It falls into a lot of bad tropes that plague fiction in all countries and really suck if you're a female viewer, or just if you happen to like any of the female characters in the show.
The show did skip over some aspects in which I think would have aided its points. It presents the stereotypical ethics questions that plague everything that discusses ethics now (trolley problem, organ transplant lottery), and it handles them fairly well. But, It does not bring up the fact that we celebrate people giving their life every day. If a fire fighter willingly runs into a burning building and gives their life to save a child, would we stop that person from doing it. No man, it's not worth it. What about on larger scale issues? In 9-11 and Australian bush fires, fire fighters and first responders literally did give their lives. Regardless of how Japan feels about war, I'm pretty sure they still have fires and other natural disasters. in a famous Russian nuclear disaster, a diver gave his life on a mission in which he would receive so much radiation poisoning he wouldn't survive after to stop the reactor from causing an even more widespread problem.
The change to philosophical discussion in the last few episodes is kind of a jarring, potentially even unwelcome change. It really does change the pacing of the show in general. While I felt the debate segment was riveting, I didn't really feel that way about the president's philosophical musings.
Overall though, I think the show handles philosophical questions better than MOST other anime that try. It blows something like Madoka's flimsy handling of many topics out of the water. In addition to that, the pacing for most of the show is excellent. It's very hard for me to watch TV series these days, and this made me want to binge. I understand the extreme that delays between episodes during its run were incredibly agonizing.
The art direction gets very playful at times, and I really found it enjoyable to see a show both with interesting art and substance. I loved the VHS effects during the interrogations, and the way the episodes play with transitions. The use of music was probably better than the music itself, it really punctuated and heightened a lot of moments. The character designs are somewhat bland, I think that really contributes to the normalcy of the world. For much of the anime you wonder rather this is paranormal or not, I think that helps greatly.
The characters were all very compelling, which is rare. I even found the antagonists to be people I wanted to know more about. I thought I would hate Nomura and Itsuki, but I didn't. While I don't care for Ai, I don't wish she wasn't in the anime (unlike someone such as Fllay in Gundam SEED). This show has a particularly hilarious portrayal of Americans that I think is underappreciated. I can't say how well it nailed other countries, but I'm guessing the people involved have actually been to America. The way the American characters conduct themselves and the conversations they have, even the historical misunderstandings are very... Relatable. Yes, we do eat Pizza on the bed.
When the president asked the mayor why he enacted a law, the mayor's response killed me. A long diatribe about how Christopher Columbus founded America and the spirit of pioneerism... Then the president just says "Ah...". Perfect.
The political systems themselves are a little questionable, but if we're being real, they aren't more questionable than when American films portray any non US government body.
The aspect I'm most ambivalent on is the ambiguity present throughout the series. It's used very well to disguise who characters are and what's going to come. I almost never knew what was happening next. At the same time, we never learn a lot about the antagonists. A question I saw pop up a lot was "When if ever is Ai controlling the main character?" We don't even know if she's controlling Itsuki. We don't know if they're equal partners, if someone even can be truly equal to Ai. We don't know if that is his son, or if anything Itsuki said is true. We don't truly know Ai's motives either. That's a lot to think about.
This ambiguity is reflected even in the ending. Still, I do think you can piece together the ending. Ending things on an ambiguous note is something common in anime and games. Lain, FF7, and Gantz all have very obtuse endings which seem to make little to no sense at first. Each one does have an explanation for it though, which you can either understand by inspecting the series, or the source material. I do believe there is something of a concrete explanation for the ending hidden within the series, but to explain it here would be spoiling it. Several people do have some very good takes though.
All in all, this is probably one of the best anime I've seen in a long time. I highly encourage people to watch it, because even if you disagree with things presented in it or don't care for the pacing of the last few episodes, you've still seen one of the best thriller/psychological/mystery anime in years. If this were a movie it'd appear on click-baity top 10 lists for its genre for decades to come.
RebelPanda
Throughout my high school years, I struggled with an illness in my mind I couldn't put into words. The way I thought of it was a roller coaster that I could never get off. My whole life has been a series of peaks and valleys. For weeks, the roller coaster would be at a peak. I would have an endless supply of energy. I was able to make friends and enjoy every day to the fullest. Then everything would crash down and suddenly the roller coaster was stuck in a valley. For weeks, I would be exhausted and depressed. Making friends was the easy part, butkeeping them was hard. During a valley, trying to talk to anyone was as painful as getting a tooth ripped out of your mouth. I had to avoid my friends altogether so I wouldn’t have an angry outburst and ruin our friendship. Growing up, I didn’t have many people in my life because I learned all of this the hard way. Even my family tried subtly avoiding me because they were afraid of sudden mood swings. There were times when the roller coaster was so low I couldn't tell if it'd ever go back up.
Babylon is like that roller coaster. It entices you with an interesting premise, it begins at the bottom of the coaster, and gradually rises. It has bursts of greatness, then it suddenly shoots downwards leaving you frustrated and trapped in the headspace of the demonic antagonist. She beckons everyone in the series, including you, to consider suicide as the answer to life-long suffering. Along the way, it touches upon—or rather, beats with a baseball bat—themes of suicide, depression, and morality. It puts a unique spin on the conventional cat & mouse murder mystery, while also tackling politics and the central theme of whether or not suicide should be legalized. Much of the screen time is dedicated to intellectual politicians debating the show’s themes. To the untrained eye, these arguments may seem intelligent, enlightening, and enthralling. Anyone who has ever taken an intro-level philosophy course can tell this entire show is pseudo-philosophical bullshit laden with logical fallacies.
It asks questions such as: Is suicide wrong? Should suicide be legal? What if someone could coerce you into killing yourself within seconds? What is it she can say to change your mind? And if you figure it out would you be convinced to join her victims? It begs you to understand these questions. If you don’t get IT, you’re the minority, if you don’t get IT you are not intelligent enough. Politicians, citizens of Japan, and entire countries vote to support the suicide law. But you simply don’t understand why because you are a normal human being. You know what's right from wrong, and you can tell that everything that occurs within the world of Babylon is illogical. Rather than asking questions rooted in modern-day society (such as the legality of euthanasia), the writer discusses the suicide law, an argument no one in the real world would benefit from pondering. No one acts like a real human being in this show. They are all cardboard cutouts existing to preach philosophy from the insidious mind of an uninformed writer.
There is no reality in which suicide will be legalized as a law. If someone is determined to take their own life, they will not stop to consider what the government has to say about it. People still have morals and know right from wrong, no decent human being would stand aside and watch a person commit suicide when they have the power to save their life. Meanwhile in the ass-backward world of Babylon... Hundreds of people commit mass suicide and the police do not investigate anything because they “want to avoid a scandal.” What the fuck. This is Japan not fucking North Korea. I find it impossible to believe the police wouldn’t care about a string of violent deaths at the same time in the same place. Babylon imagines a nightmarish perversion of reality where suicide is morally acceptable, encouraged, and the solution to depression. The sun emits a hellish hue of orange, water is colored blood-red, and the many deaths are shown in gruesome detail for shallow shock factor. The deaths also exist to get under your skin, desensitizing you to suicide at a record-breaking speed. If I had to live in a world where suicide is legal, enforced, and considered unimportant to the justice system, I wouldn’t want to live in it either.
Suicide is glorified in a way that only someone who has felt suicidal can contextualize. Like an angel of death, the Whore of Babylon whispers sweet nothings into someone’s ear and they commit suicide. Victims become crazed, there’s nothing that can stop them from the uncontrollable urge to die. This is what it is like to struggle against the overwhelming need to release yourself from the pain of life. One victim compares suicide to sex, and the end of his life is the orgasm. At the end of his monologue, he puts a gun to his head and pulls the trigger, blood squirting, but for a brief moment, it appears completely white to finish the sex metaphor. This sort of disgusting self-masturbatory directing is used throughout the show. I cannot fathom how people find this kind of unsubtle imagery remotely good. Babylon targets a large subset of the anime community who seek out mature seinen and psychological-thrillers, I consider myself part of this audience. If an anime has dark themes, dramatic music, and adult characters speaking very seriously, this subset of the community will flock to the anime. Babylon has it all, everything except the execution. I have no ill will towards anyone who likes this anime, after all, it coerces you into believing you are watching a revolutionary work of art. For me, this is one of, if not the worst, anime I have ever watched. None of the philosophical anime I have seen come close to being as pretentious as this one.
This show may have redeeming qualities: the music adds suspense, the animation is mostly acceptable, and it has an intriguing premise, but every positive aspect is doused in an impenetrable layer of poison. Babylon is an abyss with nothing at the bottom but despair and hopelessness. It gaslit me into believing its ponderings on suicide were of substance and worth reading into. Perhaps it is because I am in a valley as I write this, but analyzing Babylon made me contemplate suicide as a valid cure to a life of struggling against that roller coaster. I’m sorry this is not like my other reviews, but someone needed to warn people about this vile sack of shit. It’s about time I put this out of my mind for good. I think I’ll go outside today and enjoy the wonderful and beautiful things the world has to offer. Maybe later I will watch a comedy or a relaxing slice-of-life.
NOTE: If you have Depression, Bipolar Disorder, experienced suicidal thoughts, or a history of self-harm, please do not watch Babylon. If you are currently having suicidal thoughts, please call the National Suicide Prevention Lifeline at 1-800-273-8255.
Ackermanml
What is good ? What is evil ? What is the meaning of life ? If any of these questions pique your curiosity, I recommend you watch this show. But if you wish you have a wholesome comprehensive dark tale which with a satisfactory conclusive narrative, you are in the wrong place. My reviews would contain spoilers from this point on. So, the ending left people really disappointed. But honestly, the kind of direction this show was going, I was anticipating precisely this. First of all, this is not the kind of story with the most unique premise of 30 episodes with several seasons where we investyour hearts into. This is a 12 episodes series which is very direct with its philosophy.
The idea as it presents is that for the determination of good and evil is not possible, no matter how much science,logic and religions we add, we will keep finding gaps in our explanations. There is no definite answer, a definite truth which answers these questions, there are layers and layers of chaos and imbalance which keeps piling up one after another. What this show attempts is to give generalized answer to the idea of 'good' and 'evil'. A simple and direct truth to this issue.
And the entire premise is "have the protagonist go on this journey of discovery" based on this philosophy. And the entire show executes that through different characters. Notice that almost all the character had this conversation on 'the meaning of GOOD or JUSTICE' and their perception on the matter.
Now, the suicide law itself is not the point of the show but its implications, under the concept of good and evil.
The third act of this show is where it genuinely starts to fall apart as the show tries to address it's theme of with a bigger scope, but in the grandiosity of the setting loses the authentic and grounded touch. Nevertheless the final scene itself is what pulled me back to it.
Why did Zen shoot the president ?
So, we see that the president just moments ago convinced the the girl to wait, wait until he comes up with an answer to her question. Now, let me emphasis on the point that this is the freaking POTUS. The most powerful person on this planet. More than just a human, He is a symbol. Is it better to live or to die ? That was the question she asked. Him jumping from the ceiling means he is validating the idea that "YES, it IS 'good' to die". In his last moments he looked at Zen and apologized, because he is putting the burden of killing the president on him because that was the only way to stop him from jumping.
And now about Magase Ai, she constantly kept asking Zen, the same 2 questions. What is good ? What is evil? And in the final scene Zen finally came up with an answer, good means to 'continue' and evil means to 'end'.
That's what it all comes down to in the end. Keeping all the sense of self, moral ambiguity,preconceived principles and complexity aside. THIS is the final and direct answer he came up with.
Prior to this Magase also said to Zen that evil and good are not that different. To 'continue' and to 'end'. They are quite similar actually. It's just about what you value more. Magase is pure evil who values the act of ending and Zen values the act of continuation.
Also, I ask you as a viewer to throw all your previously conceived beliefs of what good and evil is or this show won't make any sense to you. The show tries to make a simplistic statement down to it's bare bones, and that may be unsatisfactory to some, I like to see it as another twisted yet primitive outlook of the protagonist.
Now, this is show consisted of 3 arcs. And the end of each felt like a conclusion. An end.Everything went upside down. Now what ? is the question I asked after each arc. Zen, a 'good' guy has been constantly being forced to confront the end, the evil, and in the final episode he took a person's life thus finally realizing how closely related these two are.
I believe he did shoot Magase in the end. Magase is NOT human. She is an evil incarnate who can possess the body and mind of any woman on this planet. Why do I think so?
The little kid in the post credit scene to me looked like the son of Zen, which implies Magase took the body of Zen's wife.
Zen was not killed either. He is a guy with a gun with literally no one around. He is not a madman. He posed no danger to anyone at that moment after the shooting. The only logical thing the authorities would do is apprehend him,take him into the custody, and interrogate him.
But all the things I just said about the ending is MY interpretation.
I don't know what actually happened to him because the screen cut to black. His character arc was OPEN ENDED which in turn means 'having no predetermined limit or boundary' which is roughly synonymous to CONTINUATION which is ironically what this character stands for.
On the other hand Magase only prominently appears in the very end. Throughout the show, only in the end of the episodes and the end of each arc. Thus, it's fitting that the show also ENDS with her.
And by this show's same logic, I'd like to say: the time a viewer spent watching this show, it was good ( a lot of people kept calling it an underrated gem). But the end was not conclusive, but it nonetheless is the end. (It is ironic that people are disappointed too by this ending, it cements the very idea it presents). And no matter how you put it, THAT IS EVIL.
Anax_of_Rhodes
You gotta ask yourself if you really want more seasonal schlock, or ambitious titles doing things differently, at the risk of doing them better. The only legitimate grievance I’ve read so far is episode 11 will suck if you don’t want a fairly substantial departure from the pacing and style of the previous episodes, as well as arguably disappointing discussion on fundamental morality. That’s it. Literally everything else about this show remained a solid 10/10 for me throughout. You can tell a show’s starting off STRONG when more happens in the first six minutes than other shows in entire episodes. The pacing propels the viewer forward and doesn’tlet up. Ever.
The vocal direction in BABYLON is just superb. A lot of the annoying “anime grunts” are cut; the only noises you here are the necessary ones. When a character says a name real slow, he’s focusing on it to benefit the story. When a character stutters before blabbering a weak excuse for poor performance, he’s expressing himself to benefit the story. This show doesn’t have time to waste on filler dialogue and extra sounds. It’s got 12 episodes and it’ll tell its story by the end of ‘em.
The two protagonists are good men with very different qualities and skillsets and critical flaws that their wives help them overcome. They are supported by good staff with distinct but not cliché personalities. The antagonist is not only a strategic foil, but a fundamentally moral foil as well.
BABYLON’s story starts small, growing to touch towns in major countries around the globe. Political leaders struggle to maintain the spread of the antagonist’s influence. Learned experts grapple with the moral quandary presented to them, unable to dislodge it from the public’s conscience. The mental/moral virus spreads invisibly, easily communicable to random people who showed no warning signs previously.
Just sayin’, does this at all sound like the world’s response to this little global pandemic of early 2020?
The ethical questions the show asked aren’t supposed to be answered for you by the finale. They’re answered for the characters, yes, but it’s up to you, the viewers, to munch on those thoughts awhile afterwards. It’s not pretentious; it’s provocative.
And the show just, looks, dang, artistically interesting. The sex and violence are portrayed with an unnerving lack of gratuity. The imagery complements the themes and the emotions just so well.
I got similar vibes to Death Note, but BABYLON does everything better than that. Everything. There’s a mental aspect akin to Mr. Robot. I saw hints of calm, reasoned socio-political ramifications like in Ghost in the Shell. And there’s a cast of characters here with the viability, maturity, and complexity of a Tom Clancy novel. BABYLON’s taken a lot of right choices from other media and stuffed them into these 12, quick episodes.
I understand the last 5-ish eps didn’t go over well with most viewers. Fine. But this is the kind of material I want more of, will happily support, will ardently argue in favor of. Would prefer an ambitious title that misses some people, than regular mediocrity that misses me. So, here's my 10.
ISeeLifePeople
There is a basic philosophy that has been known for a long time, What is goodness? What is evilness? This is very easy to answer, but when confronted in a universal study, this can lead to ambiguity Starting from a prosecutor who examined the case of the death of a doctor who allegedly committed suicide, felt dissatisfied the prosecutor and his colleagues further investigated the case until known the witnesses who suspected of being involved were named Ai magase. When dealing with ai magase, the prosecutor realized she was dangerous because all her actions, words, and body language could influence others. This became clearer whenthe newly elected mayor of Shiniki adopted the law on suicide.
The counter mayor tried to arrest him but his guard was very strict and also in terms of legality there was no Japanese law which made him criminal so he could not make arrests & demands officially
But more and more the lives of fellow prosecutors were lost because even some cities in the world began to adopt suicide laws. The President and the prosecutor (who received a recommendation from the FBI) cooperate to end this chaos
After the conference between countries they discussed the most crucial what is good & evil? Various statements made by them until when the president wants to answer a question that delayed before, he instead incited by ai magase which made him want to commit suicide
Here interesting part, political games & actual manipulation if the president of the US suicide, the world considers it as the right of all people and magase wins, but this is not left by the prosecutor who forced kill the US president otherwise the whole world will adopt a suicide law
Unfortunately the prosecutor Seizaki didn't shoot Ai Magase when he was right in front of him. It is true that Ai Magase & the mayor cannot be prosecuted because they are not the direct cause of people's suicides but prosecutors of Seizaki should be able to kill her for the mutilated video evidence conducted by AI Magase to his assistants
Finally, this show is very interesting overall with political, psychological, philosophical presentation which is quite logical and even a tense atmosphere in each scene but the execution that forgets the existing chronological elements makes it like a plot hole in the end of this anime
PriusKiller2
This is perhaps the biggest disappointment of 2019 and considering Carole & Tuesday exists, this is saying something. If I ever wanted a prime example of why I show a lot of hesitation to recommend something as a show is airing this is why. So to start properly let's go from the beginning. Babylon started off initially as something that is actually an interesting idea, covering suicide. The way the show treats suicide seems like it'd be very similar to the marijuana debate which is actually a great idea if it wants to present suicide as something inherently morally gray. Especially the proponent of this KaikaItsuki. But however this highlights one of the first problems of it is that rather quickly the show will disregard this morally gray stance in favor of what I dub the comic book villain, Ai Magase. So you'd think the story would present Itsuki as the antagonist especially for the protagonist Zen Seizaki but you'd be wrong it's Magase. Magase is just without a doubt evil without the slightest hint of good, she's practically as evil as Dio but Dio being evil made sense, they don't even try showing how Magase ended up being as evil as she ended up being. So naturally in a show like Babylon introducing Magase completely ruins the narrative and why would you do this? It makes no sense.
What also makes no sense in the Whore of Babylon which is supposed to be a symbol for Magase and why the show is named Babylon and that symbol is evil as in clearly not good or even in between. It's not only misplaced in this show it makes me hate the name, so this is what Babylon is named after? Wow, I'd rather them not answer that at all. Also, the “Whore Of Babylon” (Magase) has the ability to kill people by speaking vague words into their ear? I know anime isn't reality but I doubt it would go even that far this is just someone taking acid instead of a good writing class. She's definitely the worst offender of the poor characterization in Babylon with Seizaki being up there as he never really changes from being a moral puritan and if he does there aren't any sense of natural progression or an epiphany. The rivalry between Seizaki and Magase in the end feels like an inferior take of the rivalry between Tsunemori and Makishima, if anything this feels like inferior Psycho-Pass.
So in this steaming pile of crap that is this show why is it any good? I'll list two things that prevent me from giving it a one. #1 the soundtrack wasn't awful, it's just a shame it couldn't fit the tonally inconsistent mess that is Babylon. #2 the directing which I'd actually praise. The director Kiyotaki Suzuki directed Babylon amazingly well. He experiments with angles, aspect ratios, and even though Magase isn't actually that threatening of a character his direction can make her feel threatening or have quite a presence. I hope he gets better work as he has some amazing talent.
My last point of contention is the ending, while I won't spoil it in this review it's basically if Murphy's law could apply to an anime, everything that can go wrong in an ending did. It's a fireworks display of nonsensical debating, complete lunacy and utter mindlessness. It culminates into an epic shitshow that you'd have to see to believe but for now you'd have to believe me because I do not advise anyone to watch this anime at all, I doubt you'd enjoyed it, hell I didn't enjoy this anime at all, it wasn't even hilariously bad just bad. If it gave up taking itself seriously and just became a comedy it could've at least redeemed itself with that but it still would've been a horrible anime. I even enjoyed Carole & Tuesday more than this and that anime had a horrible ending as well. I'd rather watch Goblin Slayer 3 times then watch Babylon ever again.
Overall I give this a 2/10 and is one of the worst anime I've had the “honor” of completing. I'd use this as an example of what not to do when writing an anime, especially an anime focused on a morally gray topic.
Also this is my 2nd review so any constructive feedback of my review is appreciated, hope you enjoyed my review.
Serial_Exp_Lain
'Babylon' is an intelligent,logically taut series that asks important & profound questions about virtues,ethics & life itself.What starts out as a show focusing on corruption in the political & corporate world,turns into a much more complex series.The writing is brilliant.The dialogues are great.The characters are well chalked out & they remain consistent throughout the show.I don't think I am exaggerating when I say that 'Babylon' has one of the most terrifying villains in anime.Someone who would give tough competition to Johann Liebert.Our villain functions at a mental level...even without being physically present,they are able to achieve their objective just through their conversational skills.The introduction ofthis villain & their backstory is top notch.The way the anime showcases the mental state of some characters is very creative.The animation is pretty good.I have no complaints here.I liked the music too.
While tackling these difficult questions,'Babylon' doesn't offer easy answers.In fact,the characters are themselves after these answers alongwith the viewers.The show makes us question things we just don't pay much thought to.This ability to put it's themes across without being preachy in the least is one of the big wins of 'Babylon'.It handles a controversial topic in a way I have never seen handled before.The anime takes a level headed view of the world...not being too sunny & not being too cynical.It manages to capture our attention by making us invested in the characters,most importantly the protagonist.I have never felt as much sympathy for a character in a long while.
This is a damn good series that will offer enjoyment to anyone willing to think about stuff that we take for granted.
Highly recommend it!
G_ifra
Don’t watch this anime. It is pretentious shit, you will learn nothing useful, you will not find anything but boredom. If I could I would give this 0 points, this anime is a total waste of time. You don’t have to believe me, you may still want to start this anime. But when you feel the cringe level rising after 2 or more episodes come back to the spoiler section as no, it will not get better. The voice acting, music and drawing style are reasonably fine, but the action scenes are non-existent, you always arrive afterwards. This might be good enough for a detective show, butafter the first episode the anime is chasing a protagonist and it doesn’t work. There is also a lot of talking, 90% is talking going nowhere. Making it sound important and complex talking, but it really is not. In the end the anime is a simple childish script to make a dumb point. Whatever they say is mostly not shown nor has any real relevance in the anime.
[spoilers warning]
The main storyline is the adopting of a suicide law, and if suicide is bad or not.
Suicides are messy things, and laws cannot really forbid them. Existing suicide laws make it possible that people can end their lives in a painless civil way. There are requirements of course. Doctors and psychologists have to agree to it and they first check if you can be helped to live further.
But that is not researched in this anime, a requirement free law is demanded by letting people jump off of buildings. Democracy at work I’m guessing. The only argument against that law is that everyone will commit suicide on a whim, o the horror being alive really sucks. They act like a lot of people don’t do it because it’s not in the law.
The anime story show people committing suicide by jumping and shooting, which are not good ways to go. Someone has to clean the remains, imagine brains, intestines everywhere not to mention the smell. Shooting as shown in the anime is also bad as some people do survive this and end up blind. If you really want to talk about suicide - show the viewers that bloody part, that is what anime is for. Make the characters react on the view. And say without the law you get this bloody mess.
But the characters hardly react to the suicides, no one is really shocked or it goes away fast. People die, but no one is arrested because suicide is your own will of course. In this anime world, a sect leader could just do whatever they want and never be convicted.
The characters don’t feel real either, Seizaki Zen is portrayed as a good loving husband and a good colleague. But we never see him go home and have some good time with his family. Itsuki Kaika wants the suicide law so he can commit suicide to save his son. How his son feels about that is never explored, the “best dad ever” emotion should collide with “oh no daddy gone forever” emotion. His son goes with his question on the internet that’s all. And couldn’t Itsuki prepare a medical team and use one heart of the orchestrated suicides I’m thinking then, but that’s just me. That kind of logic isn’t for this anime. Although logic is apparently the strongpoint of the US president Alexander Woody, the most elaborated character of the anime. That is saying much, he was of poor health in the past, thinks a lot, plays MMORPG and also has a wife and a son. Very elaborate indeed.
Magase Ai is the protagonist of the story. Her powers are immense, she can control you totally with her voice. It’s based on something sexual and it works on all sexes. It works through telecom devices but you can’t record it. She can make herself look different to complete her power. But what are her motives exactly? You can only guess. She shows us what evil is? Is she the whore of Babylon, does she want to create Babylon?
Again details apparently, let’s just add some extra meaningless country leaders instead to make our suicide discussion international and by doing that so very important. But this adds difficulties they are clearly not ready for. It just gives you more talking. The script comes to the rescue, Seizaki Zen becomes an FBI-agent and can be at the international meeting.
In the end the president comes to his conclusion from a talk with Seizaki Zen. So why not let Zen come to that conclusion, the international thing is such a waste of time.
Magase Ai uses her powers and the script does the rest, it looks like everyone can easily walk in and out of the meeting place. They could have done so many things to protect the leaders, like a lockdown, only stun guns, no women allowed, no telecom devices, only using a chat-app to do the communication? Of course this smart anime does nothing of that and lets the president end with an earpiece that is easily accessed by Magase, at the right moment, so bye bye president. But not before he can say to us his very smart conclusion, good is continuation of life, bad is end of life.
But this message is only for the viewer as the president is on his way to jump off the building.
Zen kills the president to stop humanity of thinking that suicide is good. So ending life was good in this case easily contradicting the simple conclusion just made a second before by the thinking president. I rest my case.
Then Magase makes Zen kill himself. So what did Magase gain out of this? Ah yes it ends with Magase talking to Zen’s son. I’m guessing his bloodline will not continue. Who cares, the kid is not more interesting than the other suicide victims in this pointless story.
I know making something bad also needs effort, being a critic is way easier. If I multiply all the points it's zero in total.
My advice is to skip this pretentious anime. Nozaki Mado hasn’t reached the level of a good writer/director yet. The only good thing out of this is that I now know not to watch KADO.
